4 ms·
It is just luck. I'm a frequent reader and upvoter of the new section, and even considering possible auto-penalties, what gets upvoted can be just as dependent
by danso 13y ago
It is just luck. I'm a frequent reader and upvoter of the new section, and even considering possible auto-penalties, what gets upvoted can be just as dependent on non-content factors (which I'll conflate with "luck") as it is on actual merit.
The easiest non-controllable factor is: external exposure and canonical IDs. Some stories jump to the top not because a whole bunch of people were reading the New page, but a whole bunch of people were on Twitter/Reddit/Slashdot/NYT and then tried to be the first to submit a story...if they all used the same link, then the first submitter gets all the upvotes, and the OP benefits from that.
The second uncontrollable factor -- ostensibly -- is title. Did the OP have a great link-baity title? That'll catch the eye of New post readers. Obviously, you can take the vigilante action of writing your own title and hoping that it isn't egregious enough to get flagged before it hits the front page...but that is also "luck"
And of course, time of day and activity is important. Did your great tech blog post come at a time when Apple announced a bunch of new products, or when the NSA got caught red-handed again? Instead of 30 possible open spots on the front page, you may have been competing for 20.
---
I've seen great stories not get a single second upvote, and then resubmitted the next day and get hundreds of votes...and nothing about the user or submission would suggest that the first submitter was punished. It's just luck of the draw many times. I've managed to rack up a decent amount of karma but I've never thought it was because my submissions are higher quality than anyone else's...and conversely, people who feel they don't get any traction shouldn't take it personally.