2 ms·
So then why not control for low income or poor social conditions? Why make the connection from black\hispanic to "bad"?
by smcl 13y ago
So then why not control for low income or poor social conditions? Why make the connection from black\hispanic to "bad"?
- rayiner 13y agoFirst, because there is more to it than just income. My wife grew up in a town of about 3,000 people in Iowa. The town had poor people and rich people, but was ethnically homogenous (98% white), and everyone went to the same schools, same churches, their kids played together, etc. I've been to a similar-sized town in Illinois that is ethnically mixed (about half hispanic, half white). The hispanics in that town are poorer than the whites, as a group, go to their own church, don't speak English at home, their kids play with other hispanic kids and not so much with the white kids, though they all go to school together. Then you have places like Chicago, where a neighborhood might be 95% low income hispanic, where kids only play with other low income hispanics and go to a school that is 90%+ low income hispanic. A child with the same family income is going to nonetheless have a dramatically different experience in the three cases. They will have dramatically different experiences not because "hispanic = bad" but because the segregation is bad, and race is a powerful driver of segregation in American communities even today. I agree that it would be better to break things down into the relevant elements, instead of using race as a crude proxy. Adjust for whether parents speak English at home, adjust for educational status of parents, adjust for level of gang activity in the community, adjust for whether father figures are present, adjust for level of social integration between economic classes within the community, etc. Considering all of those things, together, would be better than using race as a proxy. But we don't keep the data in a way that would allow us to measure things that way. We keep track of racial demographics, but not things like the degree to which kids of different economic backgrounds play in mixed instead of segregated groups.
- notahacker 13y agoWell for a start, there's a very common [far]-right wing argument that Finns and Chinese are probably innately smarter due to not having many native black or hispanic citizens. You can either ignore it, or you can demolish it pointing out that black kids in certain states actually do better than the very, very white Finnish population....