3 ms·
I'd be happy to discuss with readers who disagree with this comment what the nature of your disagreement is. I think you're generally being rather kind on the
by Silhouette 13y ago
I'd be happy to discuss with readers who disagree with this comment what the nature of your disagreement is.
I think you're generally being rather kind on the not-yet-employer here, but I have one specific point: giving up a whole day of your labour for free for every interview is not a sustainable strategy.
I don't know what the average number of interviews is prior to taking a new position, but if they all last a day, that is a lot of work for each applicant to do without getting paid, and it's a lot of work from a lot of applicants that the prospective employer gets for free.
Everyone is taking a risk going through a recruitment process, but typically it's already stacked heavily in the prospective employer's favour as they set the terms of the interview and generally it's held at their choice of venue, using their preferred facilities, and with minimal overhead for their existing staff.
Throwing in working for free on the prospective employer's real project, and IMHO this tips from unbalanced to downright insulting. If you want to hire a professional, give them some professional courtesy and treat them as such.
(I would almost certainly have ended the interview in that situation as well, though perhaps not with quite the same choice of words. But then this sort of one-sided relationship is why I choose not to work for anyone as an employee any more and instead run my own businesses, so I do have a well-established bias here.)
- darkxanthos 13y agoMost interviews I've been in take essentially a whole day. Whether I add code to their codebase or not. I'd prefer working for free for the day... At least I'd have a better idea of what I'm getting into.
- Silhouette 13y agoMay I ask where you're from? I'm in the UK, and in my entire career I have never had a single visit to a prospective employer that lasted more than a half-day. It's not unusual (IME) to do that a couple of times, so maybe some places do everything on the same day, but I've never been through a recruitment process that wasn't all done in a couple of half-day visits at most. Maybe my experience is just coincidental and completely out of the mainstream.
- RogerL 13y agoI am not the person you are responding to, but multiple day interviews are pretty common in silicon valley. A few weeks ago I did a whole day interview of nothing but frigging white board exercises while they stared in their phones and look annoyed when I talked to them., and didn't question me about my resume or otherwise try to figure out if I was a fit or skilled beyond implementing memcpy twice in a row (I shit you not). That's a bit unfair, there were good questions, and good interviewers as well, but it was still just "find the bug", "implement XX". Then they called me and asked for another round. Uh, no. I then hear I'm ungrateful because they were prepared to throw a bunch of money at me. Oh la-de-friggin-da. Hmm, obviously had something to get off my chest there. But interviews can go 2-3 rounds on the phone alone, 1 day or more on technical, and then more to actually talk to the team. It works for some companies because they have a steady stream of people that want to work for "Google" or whoever. Then everyone w/o the reputation of Google decide they should be like Google, follow suit, and you have the current madness. There is the fact that a bad hire is extremely expensive, and it makes sense to be careful. But what working, skilled person has the time for such impersonal, multi-day efforts? When I put my resume on the street I had multiple inquiries from Yahoo, Amazon, Google, not to mention a bunch of smaller players. Just dealing with the proposed phone interviews would be a full time job, and I'd have to take a month off to go interview with them just to make an informed decision (why take the first job that comes along). Something is seriously broken. So long as it is possible for me I'm not going to play the game, and do it the old school way - connections, people that know my work, and so on. But the trouble is, your connection ends up at a big company, and they are powerless to stop the HR/"best practices" juggernaut.
- mellery451 13y agoThank you for shining a light on this madness. I've had the same experiences here in SV and these "extreme hiring" practices don't seem sustainable to me. I've been lately thinking that perhaps we'd be better off with a more fluid style of hiring, say something involving real probation periods after which both parties assess how things are going and decide whether to continue. That approach is complicated, though, by the fact that on-boarding an employee is costly. Perhaps THAT's what we need to optimize.