3 ms·
The OP itself says that the prosecutor (now Judge) being convicted was a huge change in procedure. It never happens. Based on your posts here, I'm getting the
by girvo 13y ago
The OP itself says that the prosecutor (now Judge) being convicted was a huge change in procedure. It never happens.
Based on your posts here, I'm getting the feeling that you are okay with the criminal justice system in the USA. You ask a lot of questions, I want to know what your stance is (honestly, I do!).
- melling 13y agoI don't have a stance. Like most people, it's not something that I really give much thought to. I'm trying to cut through the storm of complaining so I can get to the facts. What problems are you trying to solve beyond the fact that we never want someone who is innocent to go to jail?
- girvo 13y agoPersonally, my opinion is that prosecutors have incentives that don't align with the good of society (if we take "Innocent people should not go to jail" as a good thing, and a worthy goal). Their incentives are to convict as many people as possible; this case we're discussing is a good example of that effect. If you take a look at this[0], you can see that per capita incarceration in the US has grown a lot, especially over the past 30 years. So its not a baseless accusation we're talking about here. There is something driving it, and if you do a bit more research on the topic (I studied Law, so this interests me a lot), you'll find a lot more backing it up as well. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:U.S._incarceration_rates_1925_onwards.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:U.S._incarceration_rates_1...
- melling 13y agoSo, you are saying that because prosecutors are trying to convict "as many people as possible", the problem is that too many innocent people are going to jail. I think we've established this isn't the problem. People are committing "crimes", but many people feel that the crimes are too harsh. For example, someone mentioned that a crack user gets 90 days while a cocaine user only gets 30 days. Also, in the story about which we are discussing, the prosecutor broke the law. In my opinion, his punishment should have been harsher.
- wil421 13y agoI would like the police and legal system to stop looking at everyone like criminals. The concept of innocent until proven guilty is not a view seen by these people, if they come across you, youre guilty. Once I had some legal problems that got dropped, years later while applying for a permit for work at the police station, I was questioned about this incident and turned down for what I was applying for. There isnt anything on my record for this except an incident report the courts dropped it why should I still be looked down upon.