3 ms·
"I don't know enough about mechanics to make a proper assessment of this, but my bullshit detector is bleeping, though shyly." Mine too… One of the fundamenta
by bigiain 13y ago
"I don't know enough about mechanics to make a proper assessment of this, but my bullshit detector is bleeping, though shyly."
Mine too…
One of the fundamental problems regular wind turbines need to deal with is the "V cubed" term in the power contained in moving air. For exactly the same reason that you need eight times as much power to make a car go twice as fast – if you build a turbine that can produce it's "nominal power" output in, say, 10m/s (~22mph) of wind, it'll need to be able to somehow deal with the turbine operating at 8 times nominal at 20m/s (45mph, a not unreasonable occasional windspeed in many places) and 27 times nominal power at 30m/s (a high, but certainly not yet "beyond reasonable safety design limits" speed).
My problem is with the numner on their Field Data page - they say they get an average "speed Ratio" of 1.8, and their turbine is rated at "600W at 12.5m/s". Ballpark extrapolation follows. I'll assume that's 12.5m/s at the turbine, or 12.5/1.8 = ~7m/s wind speed. About 15mph. At half that windspeed, there's 8 times less energy available, so 7.5mph of breeze will generate 75W, halve it again and output at 4mph drops down under 10W, and 2mph means low single digit Watts of output.
Now think about what happens to their turbine in a stiff breeze of 30mph? Where does the 4.8kW go? and when the once-in-5-years 60mph storm comes through, somewhere the best part of 40kW needs to be dealt with. Who engineers things with almost two orders of magnitude margins of safety?
It doesn't smell right to me.
- groupthinker 13y agoVenturi effect could be used to make it a constant head of pressure. Or you could use a turbine with variable pitch and an infinitely variable transmission. Either way, agree it's hand-wavy.
- kubiiii 13y agoThere might still be something interesting in this design compared to the conventionnal wind turbines, if you imagine several output tubes and control the closing/opening of those tubes according to windspeed you'll be able to modulate the nominal power you mentionned.
- mgraczyk 13y agoThis is where the 4.8kW will go if they haven't thought of the possibility of high winds. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_e9uRSVun30 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_e9uRSVun30
- traviscj 13y agoThis seems precisely like an argument for a smaller turbine-based design INSTEAD of huge and (relatively) heavy blades. Turbines for car turbochargers and airplane engines can regularly (if I remember correctly) operate in the regime of ~100k RPM. And like other commenters say: I think it would be much easier to restrict flow in the "funnel" part and most things I can imagine for a freestanding wind machine.
- stcredzero 13y agoLooks like the blades are designed to crumple when they fail.
- jeena 13y agoCoudldn't you just close the tube? I assume they already use some kind of a one-way valve so the wind on the other side wouldn't suck and lower the preasure in the tube, you could just close this valve if the wind is too high, or even just open it a bit so you could still generate electricity?
- msandford 13y agoOr better still, provide some kind of variable restriction such that the air flow through the turbine is right at it's max operating power. Furthermore this tower isn't a lossless device, as the wind speed picks up I would guess that it gets "draggier" and less efficient at channeling and accelerating the wind. But even if that's not the case making a variable restriction that could moderate the tunnel wind speed is a very easy problem to solve. Some kind of a damper and a control system that measures wind speed and adjusts the damper accordingly. You might even be able to use the turbine to do the measuring if you're clever.
- schrodinger 13y agoDon't you need 4x the energy to make a car go 2x the velocity? The drag equation is force-drag = 1/2 p v^2 c a [1]. Or is there more at work here? 1: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_equation http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_equation
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- curveship 13y agoRight, drag scales with the square, but you're also going into that drag at a higher velocity, so power scales with the cube. Or to break it out at more length, work is force times distance, right, and power is work over time. If it takes X amount of work to cover a distance at a given speed, it takes 4X to do it in half the time, since, as you point out, the drag (force) scales with the square of velocity. But you also accomplished that work in half the time, so the power required is 8 times the original. Make sense?
- schrodinger 13y agoAhh, thank you very much! Makes sense. I was conflating work and power...
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> Now think about what happens to their turbine in a stiff breeze of 30mph? If the wind that goes into the turbine goes faster than a certain threshold, let some/most/all of the wind flow past the turbine. Maybe there is even a way to have the wind itself do that mechanically, similar to a pressure valve.
- ams6110 13y agoYou just need a "wastegate" similar to what is found on an automobile turbocharger. If too much air is moving into the generator turbine, you open some vents to bypass it.