4 ms·
So, you got me to thinking. As a side-effect of his work on expert forecasting[1], Tetlock discovered that people put more stock in those who made confident pr
by jacques_chester 13y ago
So, you got me to thinking.
As a side-effect of his work on expert forecasting[1], Tetlock discovered that people put more stock in those who made confident predictions than those who qualified their predictions. To the point that he basically says: if a person is a famous pundit, they are more likely to be wrong, because the media prefers bold predictions to maybes and perhapses.
In business you can be bold or not bold. If you're not bold, you are at a social disadvantage.
Then you can be right or wrong. If you are right, everyone hails you as a visionary. If you are wrong, nobody remembers.
So in fact, in business, the rational strategy for an individual is to speak confidently and let the dice fly high.
[1] I reviewed his book a while back. http://chester.id.au/2012/07/29/review-expert-political-judgement/ http://chester.id.au/2012/07/29/review-expert-political-judg...
- adwf 13y agoYes it's actually quite an awkward point for me at the moment. I have a side-project that I've been developing for a while. My attachment to it means that I know every single bug and flaw within the product. But at the same time I know that if I add caveats to any marketing (it's a bit alpha/beta, etc.), then it will come across as unconfident. On the other hand, if I just say it's amazing and will change your life, I'll probably (can't resist the language even now...), do far, far better.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI know how you feel. The way I deal with it is to find the claims I can confidently make and stick with those. A lot of the time you can do that by looking at the business value side of things. For example, I can't truthfully say that my code is bug free or the best or whathaveyou. But I can say "My product improves <business problem>." I guess the trick is to have two hats. The first hat is the problem domain hat. This is where you make confident, accurate claims about your product. The second is the solution domain hat. This is where you park your professional anxieties about whether you've crossed and dotted everything.
- eved1973 13y agoThat reminds me of a story I heard about doctors who are asked to determine the gender of a baby during a pregnancy scan. They will announce the gender to the parents verbally (It's a boy!), but put the other gender in their files. If you do end up having a boy, it doesn't go further. If you end up having a girl, and question the doctor, he/she points to the file and says "You must have misunderstood what I said".
- dennisgorelik 13y agoPeople don't care much if pundits are right or wrong. Instead people care that pundits are clear (confident statements help with clarity). Qualifiers are substituted by getting multiple opinions from different pundits.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI suppose I should have added that the confident pundits were usually wrong because they tended to make more extreme predictions. Most of the time, stuff doesn't change dramatically. Predicting big shifts all the time means that your overall hit rate is terrible, because big shifts are not the most common case. Luckily there's an extreme predictor for every extreme event, so simple selection happily promotes some loudmouths to guru every now and then.