4 ms·
There's an interesting hole in the data at 4 & 10 on the opponent's 36. In a sea of punting and kicking, this one data point has actual coaches going for it. A
by vacri 13y ago
There's an interesting hole in the data at 4 & 10 on the opponent's 36. In a sea of punting and kicking, this one data point has actual coaches going for it.
Also, looking at the overall pattern of the data, my gut tells me that the optimal rubric is somewhere in-between the 'bot and the meatcoach. There are some strange holes as well - at 4th&3, you should go for if you're on your own 8 or 9, but punt if you're on your own 7 or 10?
- judk 13y agoWithout confidence levels, the differences are meaningless. Maybe that's the flip from 49% to 51%
- thejteam 13y agoThat makes sense. At the 36, it is a 53 yard or so field goal. At the outer range of most kickers and pretty low percentage, so you give the ball to the opponent at the 40 something yardline with high probability. On the other hand, its also close enough to be very difficult for a punter to pin in inside the 5 or 10, so even if you fail you only give the opponent 16 yards over a punt. But the holes at the your own end you mentioned, that makes no sense at all.