4 ms·
Your posts continue to be dominated by argument for the subject matter, when we are now discussing discourse. Restricting my discussion our point of contention
by dllthomas 13y ago
Your posts continue to be dominated by argument for the subject matter, when we are now discussing discourse. Restricting my discussion our point of contention:
"There's ... a lot of history behind that term."
There is practically no history behind the term "libertardian": https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=libertardian https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=libertardian - there is arguably history behind libertarians being wrong (which is what you go on to talk about), but that does not in any way motivate the specific term.
"My experiences in both dealing with present-day defenders of Libertarianism and in going to its roots, foundations, and the considerable machinations behind it have lead me to conclude that most of those who defend the tradition 1) fail to understand it and/or know its roots, 2) lack the ability to do so, 3) are paid for their opinions, and/or 4) fully understand the inherent contradictions but find it convenient and in their interest to promulgate a false philosophy for their own benefit."
And considering those people, which of them are going to be inclined to "see the light" because you called them a "libertardian"? How many are just going to stop listening to you? How many non-libertarians are going to start ignoring your criticisms of libertarianism because you are being disrespectful and offputting?
"At which point the respect I show rapidly dwindles."
And the point at which you stop showing respect is the point at which I start calling you out for it on HN.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThere is practically no history behind the term "libertardian" I should have clarified: personal history. That said, I thought I was being original when I coined it and found (with some satisfaction) that I wasn't. Convincing people of their follies isn't my primary goal. Understanding their follies and the dynamics behind them are. While I generally don't launch into discussions spewing "libertardian" (present instance being an exception), I do use the term. More often in referring to the philosophy and those who claim adherence to it (itself fraught given the lack of cohesion it and they exhibit). Of the four cases of adherents I describe, only one is likely to be persuaded by facts and/or reason anyway, typical of any other faith-based religion which puts belief over evidence. So my success rate would of necessity be quite limited. And the point at which you stop showing respect is the point at which I start calling you out for it on HN. As I said: the lack of respect for facts and reason (of which there's a long personal history), and the tedium in repeatedly plowing that ground, is why I've resorted to a memetic shortcut which encapsulates if not elucidates the fundamental flaw. That said, while acknowledging your call out, it doesn't in the last bother me for the reasons stated above.
- dredmorbius 13y agoAnd just to showcase an example, from one of the Brin G+ threads I mentioned earlier: https://plus.google.com/116665417191671711571/posts/1dqQKTz8ACi https://plus.google.com/116665417191671711571/posts/1dqQKTz8... Three points in particular to call out: 1. Brin is absolutely correct in noting that Libertarians don't read or understand Smith (neither do most economists, but that's another story, see Gavin Kennedy for detailed scholarship on the "invisible hand"). 2. Theodore Minick exhibits a very frequently encountered tactic of redefining well-defined terms to suit his argument (and failing to provide those definitons). When I pull out a half dozen or so dictionary definitions that discredit his use, his response is "the accepted definition also conflates 'market' and 'marketplace'". Sorry, but if you can't agree on base facts, you've got no grounds for discussion. You've just got a Lewis Carroll "glory". 3. Another respondent claims that Reason.org references Smith often. So I search for references ... and find that most are blithe (and inaccurate based on scholarship) references to the "invisible hand" and little else. Which is to say: the leading Libertarian publication similarly gets its facts and relevance almost entirely wrong. And as I said: the experience is far too frequently repeated. Any respect I had has long since been extinguished.
- dllthomas 13y agoAs I think I've said, but may've neglected, I've absolutely no problem with you arguing your point (either directly or through secondary sources). I only object to lack of respect which makes my job harder when I need to criticize someone's position, because I run the risk of sounding like you.
- dredmorbius 13y agoIf I've resorted to "Libertardian" (and I do that fairly frequently) within a discussion, it's usually an indication that I've reached one of the many impasses I all-too-frequently encounter. And am indicating that Gish galloping, factual and logical errors, argumentum ad nauseum, and similar tactics, are all being indicated but won't be specifically addressed, simply because that serves no use. As I said: my usual goal in those discussions is to see if there's any merit at all to either the arguments of, or discourse with, a specific person. I've yet to be convinced. When I repeatedly call out an individual's failings (Noel Yap would be another G+ instance) and they never once apologize or admit error ... again, any last shred of respect has been lost. In his case I'd largely taken to deleting his idiotic comments to my own posts, and finally just blocked him -- the idiocy was too much to take. The icing in his case was repeatedly failing to read or comprehend the text directly before him to which he was responding. When I make a glaring error, and am called on it, I admit it and appreciate the correction. I don't insist on being wrong. What is it you perceive your job as?