3 ms·
The problem with the education system is similar to that of a corporation, or politics. Nobody who sees the need for changes has the authority to make those cha
by peterwwillis 13y ago
The problem with the education system is similar to that of a corporation, or politics. Nobody who sees the need for changes has the authority to make those changes, and those in authority do the bare minimum needed to keep their jobs.
I was expelled or "asked to leave" from several high schools (in Broward County) when I was growing up about 12 years ago. Ironically, it was never for drugs or misbehavior, but instead for being too smart for my own good. The offenses were always minor: a "dangerous" amount of "knowledge of school computer systems". Pushing a chair across the room "in a violent manner" (fast enough to make it clang into the wall). Strange electronics diagrams that they could not decipher (an FM transmitter project kit from RadioShack). Having a website with links to VisualBasic AOL proggies and punters that "could be slowing down the Mac network".
What it took me years to figure out was that nobody wanted to deal with a special case. Nobody wanted to take the time to help you or understand you. They have thousands of kids to deal with. They're happy as long as everyone is towing the line and they'd much rather get rid of you (or pass you) than educate you. And I can sum up the motivation in one sentence:
There is zero incentive for educators to help troubled kids.
- VLM 13y ago"There is zero incentive for educators to help troubled kids." Brevity is overrated; none the less strike out "troubled".
- peterwwillis 13y agoNot so fast. There are incentives for teachers to help talented, excelling individuals who have no problems. It makes the teacher and the school look good, especially for local and national government programs that reward teachers/schools with good results. You could say this is much more relevant in universities where millions of dollars may hinge on the ability of a student to develop something the school can shop around. Actually, there is one incentive for teachers to help troubled kids: High school and college sports. The sports brings in the money, and so they need to make sure the kids don't completely fail out so they can keep bringing in the dough. Other than that, though...
- dragonwriter 13y ago> There are incentives for teachers to help talented, excelling individuals who have no problems. It makes the teacher and the school look good, especially for local and national government programs that reward teachers/schools with good results. The incentives are actually reversed in the era of NCLB, where the most important measure isn't how good the best results are, but what proportion aren't meeting the minimum standards for their grade level. This provides incentives to: 1) Improve the performance of the worst performing students if it is cheap to do, 2) Get the worst performing students out of the system if it is not cheap to improve their performance, 3) Avoid accelerated promotion of students that are performing at a higher grade level and not challenged, so as to make the percentages look better. > Actually, there is one incentive for teachers to help troubled kids: High school and college sports. The sports brings in the money, and so they need to make sure the kids don't completely fail out so they can keep bringing in the dough. As I understand it, for the most part, high school and college sports bring in money (if at all) for the sports program, not the school at large.
- Shish2k 13y ago> Nobody wanted to take the time to help you or understand you On behalf of several ex-teacher friends, a minor correction -- there are teachers who care, and go out of their way to help the special cases; but the system treats them just as badly as it treats the special kids themselves, so they tend not to stay in that career for very long.
- chris_mahan 13y agoBut then that's even worse.
- dredmorbius 13y agoNice recent interview on NPR with their sports reporter Mike Pesca and a former teacher of his: "Remembering when a teacher had his back" http://www.npr.org/2013/11/24/246984890/remembering-when-a-teacher-had-his-back http://www.npr.org/2013/11/24/246984890/remembering-when-a-t... "I always thought — I never questioned it — I always thought you had my back," Pesca tells Sheehan. "Back then, I would say that school was enjoyment for you, and maybe not necessarily the classes," Sheehan recalls, laughing. "For a lot of teachers you were problematic, so part of my job was really to keep you from being thrown out of that school. That passion is kind of what drove you in school." It was the same passion that drove Pesca to push the boundaries, he says. Sheehan remembers a problem-solving program in nearby Katonah, in which gifted students were given a problem to solve and then present in a skit. Pesca's skit: "The Top 10 Things We Hate About Katonah" — a sort of David Letterman-esque spoof. "The guy running that program practically wanted to have you arrested," Sheehan says. "That night, I did have your back."
- walshemj 13y agoYes I wondered as a dyslexic how I woudl have fared in today's schools. I was in the small group who had reading ages well above the norm who where allowed to read by our selves in a corner. These days certainly in the UK all the effort is put into the borderline kids to get them from a D to a C as the number of C GCSE's is a key metric
- DanBC 13y agoPeople may be interested in the UK documentaries "Educating Essex" and Educating Yorkshire". http://www.channel4.com/programmes/educating-essex/4od http://www.channel4.com/programmes/educating-essex/4od http://www.channel4.com/programmes/educating-yorkshire/4od http://www.channel4.com/programmes/educating-yorkshire/4od
- vonmoltke 13y agoI was fortunate in that, when I was recognized as a special case in elementary school (in Broward County), my parents were well-enough known at the school that I was able to get special arrangements. It was also 1988 and thus before public education administration really started going south. I also was not the type to push rules, which no doubt made things easier as well. Still, as an "exception" I got lumped into the ESE bucket with every other kid, regardless of reason, that did not fit the mainstream path.
- GauntletWizard 13y agos/troubled//