3 ms·
I disagree; the idea that we can write a complete rule set for humans is something that has tempted humans for a long time, but there's no evidence we can pull
by jerf 13y ago
I disagree; the idea that we can write a complete rule set for humans is something that has tempted humans for a long time, but there's no evidence we can pull it off. How does your rule set handle "Student A sneaks some aspirin into Student B's backpack"? A strict reading says that Student B has some aspirin. Obviously that is not what was meant, but we can't afford to specify all the "obviously"s, and it's probably just plain impossible.
- ds9 13y agoWe don't have to have perfect rules, we just have to go from "crazy over-inclusive and treat all violations alike" to "reasonably targeted and allow for severity of the violation".
- DanBC 13y agoThe basic concept of zero tolerance would handle this fine. B is a victim. A is a perpetrator. The type of drug sets the punishment. Drugs would normally mean recreational drugs. Aspirin is not recreational, so A doesn't need punishment for carrying this drug. But medical drugs, even aspirin, need cautious use and A should be told about the risks of handing out medication to other people, and about the stupidity of sneaking stuff into other people's bags. The zero tolerance policy has handled the situation appropriately. A not-zero-tolerance policy would have said "Bah, we've got better things to worry about than that" and not done anything to A. Unfortunately, what zero tolerance means in most implementations is that B gets no opportunity to explain that they're a victim, and thus B is expelled from that school. And if A is caught they're also expelled.
- kps 13y agoThis is (arguably) the difference between civil law and common law systems — the former seeking to codify correct rules in advance, the latter to adapt rules correctly to new circumstances.
- Thrymr 13y agoWhich is one of the advantages to a jury trial in criminal proceedings, so that a defendant's peers can evaluate the circumstances surrounding the alleged crime. Traditionally judges in the USA have considerable leeway in sentencing as well, though mandatory minimums and "three strikes" laws have eroded that. In schools, "zero tolerance" rules take away the leeway of administrators to make punishment proportional and humane. Going down the road of making better rules that can be perfectly enforced is exactly the wrong direction.