3 ms·
A few comments based on my experience working with these things back in 2009 [0] 1. Yes, this thing has a mortality rate of 30%. What that means is that out of
by Anon84 13y ago
A few comments based on my experience working with these things back in 2009 [0]
1. Yes, this thing has a mortality rate of 30%. What that means is that out of all detected cases 30% of the people have died. The keyword here is detected. At this stage, and without a massive surveillance plan looking for specifically for serological evidence of the virus, authorities are only aware of a tiny fraction of the actual cases (the most severe) which tend to skew the mortality rate. The actual mortality rate for the 2009 H1N1 has just now been reevaluated with more accurate data and techniques [1, 2]
2. So far it doesn't seems to have crossed the threshold to be able to spread quickly from person to person. Doing that will imply a few more mutations that will likely make it less aggressive and deadly (it's hard to spread if you kill your host too quickly).
3. Better than watching Contagion to get an idea of what a spread looks like at a global scale is to watch [3] which is an accurate representation of the H1N1 spreade in 2009. Each edge you see represents the (likely) first infected person traveling from an infected to an uninflected city. You can play with the (client) software we used for these simulations over at [4]
4. Attempts to use real time proxy data like mentions in Twitter and searches in Google to monitor the spread of infectious diseases haven't really been very successful. Google flu trends had some early success but it seems to be breaking down recently. As usual Twitter seems to be much better at predicting the past than the future. In fact the CDC has recently launched a competition to try and do just this [5]
5. In summary, don't panic. Much smarter people than myself are keeping an eye on this and it's likely not as bad as the link baity headlines would have you believe.
[0] I worked directly with the official surveillance data and used it to model And forecast the worldwide spread of the virus. We were actually able to predict (and publish) the epidemic peak for dozens of countries I'm advance You can access all the relevant publications here: http://www.bgoncalves.com/publications.html http://www.bgoncalves.com/publications.html
[1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2013/11/26/247379604/2009-flu-pandemic-was-10-times-more-deadly-than-previously-thought http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2013/11/26/247379604/2009-fl....
[2] http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pmed.1001558 http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fj...
[3] http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YAf1aXCvvdU http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YAf1aXCvvdU
[4] http://www.gleamviz.org/simulator/ http://www.gleamviz.org/simulator/
[5] https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2013/11/25/2013-28198/announcement-of-requirements-and-registration-for-the-predict-the-influenza-season-challenge https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2013/11/25/2013-281...
Edit: spelling
- Renaud 13y agoBeing in Hong Kong and having lived through the SARS era, I'm happy when someone brings us back to reality and doesn't play the OMG-we'll-all-gonna-die scenario. In the case of SARS, even though it killed more people in Hong Kong than anywhere else -many of them doctors and nurses-, the secondary effects of the disease affected everyone here: travel to Hong Kong stopped, the economy tanked, companies and shops closed and people lost their livelihood, no-one wanted to invest, everyone was afraid. We should always be careful with the headlines.
- ddeck 13y ago>Being in Hong Kong and having lived through the SARS era, I'm happy when someone brings us back to reality and doesn't play the OMG-we'll-all-gonna-die scenario. I couldn't agree more. Even SARS, concerning as it was when its pathology was unknown, was associated with fewer deaths in Hong Kong than influenza during the same year.
- feral 13y ago>2. So far it doesn't seems to have crossed the threshold to be able to spread quickly from person to person. Doing that will imply a few more mutations that will likely make it less aggressive and deadly (it's hard to spread if you kill your host too quickly). I've done some epidemiology, but I'm not a biologist. I don't understand your line of reasoning there. I suspect it stems from a logical mix-up, but its not detailed enough to say for sure. I understand that if a disease kills its host, before it can infect more people, then it will 'burn itself out' and fail to spread. Therefore, all other things being equal, a disease that kills more slowly, or kills less, will spread more. However, that does not mean that a disease must become less aggressive and deadly to spread quickly from person to person - or even has pressure to. We can use the terminology of compartmental epidemiology modelling to make this clearer: - The rate which describes how contagious the disease is, between an infected person, and a non-infected person: 'B' (beta). - The rate a which someone infected becomes non-infective (recovered or dead): 'v'. - Lets also talk about the mortality rate, the % of infected people who become dead, rather than recovered. You say: >(it's hard to spread if you kill your host too quickly). I interpret that as a statement about 'v': you are saying that if the disease kills too quickly, it won't spread too fast. That's true - if 'v' is much shorter than a normal flu - let's say its minutes, as an illustrative unrealistic extreme - then clearly even a very contagious disease (high Beta) will burn itself out. However: > So far it doesn't seems to have crossed the threshold to be able to spread quickly from person to person. That is a statement about 'B'. You imply that it is necessary, or likely, that 'v' changes as 'B' increases. But what reason do you have to think that? There's no reason to think that a disease couldn't have a normal 'v' (couple of weeks; but even a couple of days would probably still be incredibly dangerous), but a really high 'B' and a really high mortality rate, if we are very unlucky. The mutation of the disease isn't guided, or intelligent; it doesn't care if it reaches equilibrium with its host population, or kills us all. The evolutionary pressure on the disease to become less lethal is a populations-of-diseases level pressure (i.e. the specific disease will die, if it kills all humans); whereas the evolutionary pressure to spread more applies at the level of individual members of this specific disease (which is normally how we think about evolutionary pressures). Why think there's a casual link from the former to the latter? I believe your argument mixes the two up, leading to a faulty conclusion, and an unwarranted assumption of an extra safety factor. I've seen a number of people working in the area of epidemiology make what I think is this mistake, and I'd like to know whether I'm missing something or they are.