7 ms·
I don't think it's unreasonable to expect that a website which people are legally obligated to use by a certain deadline, entering very sensitive information in
by andrewflnr 13y ago
I don't think it's unreasonable to expect that a website which people are legally obligated to use by a certain deadline, entering very sensitive information in the process, have a decent standard of security at launch. I don't see "having the crap beat out it in production" as a good strategy here, and certainly is worth complaining about, even if not worth re-writing over. Would you be comfortable entering your SSN at healthcare.gov?
- tptacek 13y agoLast first: yes. For the rest: if you have standards or expectations for the security of any site than handles your personal information, you are bound to be disappointed. I am less worried about the information I post to a site like Healthcare.gov than I am about online banks. How secure do you think new, production, real-money online banking sites are? Here's a hint: you have more to worry about than open redirects.
- andrewflnr 13y agoWell, that's horrifying too. My point stands, at least from a perspective of moral obligation. I'll grant I'm not optimistic about it working out in real life.
- patio11 13y agoFun fact: You can guess an individual's SSN using information often available on their Facebook profile and about 100 lines of code. (Someone demonstrated this to me using a TI-82 program in high school. The result has since been replicated in more reputable literature. http://www.ssnstudy.org/ http://www.ssnstudy.org/)
- borski 13y agoMan I remember learning this and having my mind blown. It's scary.
- Amadou 13y agoI don't see "having the crap beat out it in production" as a good strategy here Absolutely. The people who will pay the price for that design philosophy are not the ones making the decision to use that design philosophy. It really doesn't matter if poor security engineering is the common case, we should expect better from a modern system with the budget of a federal project and the legal requirement that we use it.
- tptacek 13y agoI hope I don't sound like I'm sticking up for the procurement process that generated this site. The site was bought was, I'm sure, a pile of poop. I just have trouble with people's utterly unrealistic expectations of how security works in real applications. Forget Healthcare.gov; I mean real applications, ones people rely on every day. Nothing is secure from the start. Everything has bugs.
- Amadou 13y agoNothing is secure from the start. Everything has bugs. Sure, all aspects of programming are subject to bugs. My concern with the site is an apparent lack of design for security. Admittedly the linked article only talks about symptoms, I'm inferring poor design from a previous article which said the developers put security at the bottom of the list of priorities.