4 ms·
I think the lesson to take from this whole fiasco is not that anything the government does is bound to fail, but that the redundancy offered by multiple competi
by andrewflnr 13y ago
I think the lesson to take from this whole fiasco is not that anything the government does is bound to fail, but that the redundancy offered by multiple competing entities trying to do the same thing is valuable. Everyone here knows software projects have a high failure rate, especially those with complicated specifications. Trusting something as important as a national health care system to the success of one project seems insane to me.
- dreamdu5t 13y agoI don't buy it. This contractor got paid. I don't see how a business would pay a contractor for not delivering, and if they did deliver and the product was crap, they would directly suffer as a result. The only reason the government has to change healthcare.gov is because it's an issue that republicans have put on TV to use against democrats. That's it. If it sucked, but wasn't in the news cycle (like everything else), then the government wouldn't do a damn thing about it.
- Tloewald 13y agoSo, do you have any experiemce of consulting work (I mean the big firms like McKinsey and Accenture)? Most consulting work comprises being paid handsomely for failing to deliver. Sometimes they get paid to destroy companies. (I think McKinsey has run some countries into the ground.)
- andrewflnr 13y agoI'm confused about whether/how you disagree with me. In case it wasn't clear, I'm generally in favor of private enterprise being in charge of things; I'm trying to rein in my "government is stoopid!" instincts a bit :). Generally, it seems stupidity of an organization scales with the number of people therein, private or not. Even corporations let horrible products persist if they don't hear enough whining. Government just has some extra features that make it bad at projects like this.
- yogo 13y agoThe way I see it is that that parties contracted to build these systems are not invested in its success whatsoever. Payment is guaranteed and you can keep on billing. It's not a trivial software system but it's a lot different when the livelihood of your company depends on it. It's a valuable lesson for the states and government but I'm skeptical as to whether anything would change.
- sseveran 13y agoIn fact the economic incentive is often to never really be done. I saw this first hand at a couple of government agencies.