2 ms·
He sounds like an enthusiastic presenter, but he does not write particularly well: "An enthusiastic audience is the best kind; to get people excited about scie
by cafard 13y ago
He sounds like an enthusiastic presenter, but he does not write particularly well:
"An enthusiastic audience is the best kind; to get people excited about science is a sight to behold. When it came to talking about gold and in particular the human obsession with it I showed a picture of the iconic scene in Goldfinger where Bond discovers Jill Masterson dead and gilded."
He seems from his account to be longer on enthusiasm than on content, which is well enough, I think, if one is lecturing to students in the primary grades. But--I don't know the English system--aren't these students in the secondary grades, and shouldn't we beyond the "science can be cool stuff"?
I'm pretty sure that while still in the primary grades I knew about gold's ductility, malleability, resistance to most solvents, etc., all of which tidbits, if not science do have something more to do with it than a gilded actress. Or maybe this is just sour grapes because my parents wouldn't let me see the Bond films the first time around?
- ColinWright 13y agoAs mentioned elsewhere, I give about 150 talks a year, and have been doing presentations for over 25 years. Jamie is exactly the sort of presenter that gets otherwise jaded, bored, and disengaged kids back into enjoying science. Yes, this was to secondary school aged students, probably about 15 years of age, and I've seen him excite and engage similar audiences, and get them buzzing about how science can be interesting. Maybe he doesn't write well, but his account was of this incident, and not intended to be of the science content. Maybe you're right, maybe we should be beyond the "science can be cool" stuff, but my personal experience tells me we're not. Not by a long chalk.