4 ms·
Note: the following comment is based as my experience as an engineering officer in the RAAF, with cryptographic clearance (someone has to load the keys into the
by antimagic 13y ago
Note: the following comment is based as my experience as an engineering officer in the RAAF, with cryptographic clearance (someone has to load the keys into the crypto devices!).
Yes, as anyone that has ever had a security clearance knows, the biggest target of humint is sigint. The level of clearance that is needed to handle cryptographic material is higher than the clearance to know about the information sent by the cryptographic system. That's because one piece of information, no matter how sensitive, is nowhere near as damaging as being able to read all encrypted material of your enemy.
Clearances aren't just a title that you get - an increase in your security clearance goes hand in hand with your history coming under heavier scrutiny. At first you might just get a cursory check to verify that you are who you say you are - teachers from your school may be contacted, neighbours etc. As you start gaining access to cryptographic networks, the checks start going into who you associate with, what your hobbies are, what's happening in your bank account. And the checks get more discreet - you might learn about your primary school teacher getting asked questions about you, but you won't learn that your telephone conversations were listened to for 6 months to make sure you're not hanging out with $THREAT_DU_JOUR.
So if sigint is valuable, one of the best ways to get your hands on it is to compromise someone that has access - in other words humint. The two are not disassociable.
- frandroid 13y agoBut once again, that is internal and defensive humint, not external humint. The main point of the article, that spies don't discover anything useful about foreign enemies, remains.
- antimagic 13y agouh, I think you missed my point. The reason that you get your background checked so thoroughly is because you're going to be a target of the bad guy's humint (so that he can use your access to cryptosystems for sigint), so the good guys vet you first to find the skeletons in your closet. This is most definately offensive humint.
- onetwofiveten 13y agoThat's an interesting point. If piece of information X is easy to verify, then so is piece of information Y where Y is some blackmail material on an individual who knows X. That does make sense.