5 ms·
Ask Hackers and PG: Weigh votes by karma?
I'm a bit slow (and may have missed a previous discussion). I'm not sure how the editors can protect the integrity of submissions without having a broad sampling of editors. But isn't that the community already? It seems like the best protectors are those that hang out here the most and have been rewarded most by the community. So, why not simply weigh votes by karma? Here the people already proven to know how this community "works" would be given a louder voice. Those that hang out less often would have less of a voice and all would earn their voice with submissions that best conform to the varied tastes of the community. Heck, it could even go one layer deeper. Karma from discussions and stories could weigh the respective votes. Each aspect of the site would therefore be best supported by those folks who put in the most recognized intellectual work.
- bootload 19y ago"... So, why not simply weigh votes by karma? ..." It's been mooted before & discussed a bit. I thought the response was a combination of editors (who delete posts, make titles readable) and upvoting by users. Poor submissions simply sit around 1 and just never make it to the /news stack. Can you give examples of where the "integrity of submissions" warrant what you suggest?
- robg 19y agoIgnore those low-recognized submissions and the associated points. By "integrity", I just meant a way to protect from drift. If the early users "know" the community, and they soon get overrun by newbies (the Reddit phenomenon), then why not give those early/frequent users a greater voice? A newbie would still get their voice amplified as they show they "understand" the community (i.e., accumulated karma). I'm cool with editors fixing and deleting posts. But amplifying their voice in votes seems more problematic - both technically and from a community-stand point. Why not let the "best" voters simply emerge from the community esprit de corps? That's not to say a great voter is anyone above some predetermined ceiling - just that community knowledge increases as a function of karma - weight the votes accordingly and you protect the community while respecting every user's contribution.
- bootload 19y ago"... just that community knowledge increases as a function of karma ..." Reasonable approach similiar to perlmonks where you have to earn rights instead of being "gifted" them. The karma approach breaks down if you assume karma is permanent ~ http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=63583 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=63583 An effective way is to be familiar with hacker submission names from the leader board or read the comments. I do like your idea though and it's something I wish existed on /. a long time ago when the "hoards" found it.
- robg 19y agoIt's never too late since the early adopters would still have more accumulated karma. But you're right - if they aren't as active as they were you could run into a community that wants to pass them by (viva la revolution!) but is hindered by the status quo. Still, with so many voices, I'm not sure I'd be concerned. Anyone who accumulates karma would get the voice to match. P.s. I say all this knowing that my own votes would likely lose value. But that's cool with me since I don't get to hang out here as much as I'd like. Better to make the keepers of the community the ones who have the most invested. What's nice about karma is that it's recognition by other community members that your voice matters.
- h34t 19y agoDoesn't a user's karma say more about how much time they have to contribute to Hacker News than about how good their judgment is?
- rms 19y agoit certainly says much more about the time spent contributing than anything about quality
- robg 19y agoI suppose you'd just have to exclude submissions where the total points never reached some predetermined floor - say 5 or 10 points. That would eliminate all the points accumulated from submissions and comments that were not received well. And you'd still have a measure of the users who "understand" the community.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoSo I'm got some free time this week and I've been submitting and commenting every day. PG gets a lot of votes cause, well, he's PG. Some other people don't participate a lot, but they've been on since it started. One guy might make funny comments that everybody wants to see at the top of the page. What about any of this would be indicative that giving these people more say than others would be a good thing to do?
- pg 19y agoWe'd only use scores of submitted links, not comments. BTW, I don't get the most votes: http://ycombinator.com/newsnews.html#6aug07 http://ycombinator.com/newsnews.html#6aug07 (Paul is Paul Buchheit.)
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoAs long as karma expired, that'd work. You'd get a continuously-changing list of group "owners" who, by their participation and group recognition, control the content ratings of the board. It would also be good to make some allowance for the new guy, who gets 5 votes but yet his article didn't make it to the front page. Some kind of indication that it's a weighted system. Perhaps computing the weight at the time of votes, and only showing the weighted total.