4 ms·
this article has an active agenda and seems to overlook signals intelligence successes against militaries and governments. history is filled with (public) succe
by munin 13y ago
this article has an active agenda and seems to overlook signals intelligence successes against militaries and governments. history is filled with (public) success stories where espionage delivers the goods, ENIGMA, purple, ivy bells, etc... espionage also played a very large role in deception and counterintelligence in concealing facts around d-day from the axis powers.
to be fair, espionage and intelligence gets it wrong very often. the goal of intelligence, though, is to find some truth in an uncertain situation and the presence of active deception. this is hard enough when you're talking about figuring out another government.
I think there's an interesting argument around whether or not a "traditional" government spy agency is "nimble" enough to analyze and understand modern organized crime and terrorist groups, but it's both an argument that I think intelligence professionals have been having for quite some time, and an argument the author of this blog is not interested in considering...
- willvarfar 13y agoThe article mentions both enigma and purple. And can you elaborate in which way was ivy bells catch useful?
- munin 13y agothe article states: > was helped by the Poles who had stolen a machine before the outbreak of war, which is false! the poles actually built an ENIGMA after analyzing encrypted traffic, see this book: http://www.amazon.com/dp/0743217349 http://www.amazon.com/dp/0743217349
- willvarfar 13y agoSo you are saying that the small credit he gave humint in the enigma matter may in fact not be deserved? Surely this makes your argument weaker than ever? Slightly off topic, but you may enjoy this on my blog: http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/19946053957/enigma-spreadsheet http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/19946053957/enigm...