3 ms·
I've been on stage when there's been an inappropriate response from an audience. In one case it turned out that a phrase I used had a specific and completely u
by ColinWright 13y ago
I've been on stage when there's been an inappropriate response from an audience. In one case it turned out that a phrase I used had a specific and completely unexpected meaning in that geographical area. I looked it up later, and I'm not surprised it got the response it did.
But having got that at an unexpected moment, when you're on stage in front of a large audience, working out the exact correct response can be difficult. Really difficult. To the point where you need not to respond immediately, and give it time.
I'm spoken with the author, and he's used this exact presentation in the past with a variety of audiences and had no inappropriate responses before this one. There was no a priori reason to believe this occasion would be different, and I think his response was perfectly reasonable.
You, speaking in hindsight, will have a different point of view. For me, as a speaker with over 150 engagements every year, having given presentations to various audiences for the last 25 years, I think your assessment is misguided.
Yes, there are serious issues here that need to be addressed, and no doubt there will be many self-appointed experts about what should and shouldn't be done, shown, and said. Personally, when something like this happens I think it's brave for a speaker to put in the public domain the choices made in the moment, in front of an audience, with no time to choose your words.
- quesera 13y agoHe trotted out sexualized imagery, and objected when a subgroup of adolescent boys connected Nigella and Bond girls to sex instead of his intended SCIENCE. There is science in food, but Nigella is not in the science camp of the food media world. In hindsight, his error should be obvious even to him. He addressed that point not at all, instead focusing on the offensiveness of adolescent boys. I can appreciate that perhaps he wasn't prepared for this audience, and I certainly agree that an unexpected response requires the speaker to improvise. He improvised poorly, as many of us would, even experienced speakers. That's not my objection. My objection is that he doesn't own up to his part in the construction. If he was presenting it any less triumphantly, I'd give him the benefit of the doubt. He taunted, and tried to shame, a rabble of 15-year old boys. That never ends well, and even if you pull off the most honorable response possible, your victory is hollow. He should realize that, at least.
- ColinWright 13y agoMuch of what you're saying was said by someone on Twitter, and the original author has responded to that: Submitted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6835021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6835021
- quesera 13y agoProbably not worth a submission of its own, but the Twitter-er said it all far better than I: http://therationaliser.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/the-peacock-problem-response.html http://therationaliser.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/the-peacock-pr... And the original speaker comes off defensive and simultaneously pleased with himself in his response: http://www.jamiebgall.co.uk/the-peacock-problem-response/4581250090 http://www.jamiebgall.co.uk/the-peacock-problem-response/458... If he can't see that adolescent boys will generally not be on their best behaviour, and will almost always take rebuke from a stranger on a stage -- that they don't even want to be in the audience of -- as a challenge to be met with volume...well he doesn't get it. Ironically, perhaps, he's running the same game as the adolescents in his defense of his actions. I didn't do it, you misunderstood, it wasn't that bad, so what anyway, eff off if you disagree, I'm a great speaker so you're obviously wrong, etc. (Also, did he mean Qatar the country with stellar womens' rights, where he was invited to give the speech again, after his performance?)
- theorique 13y agoWhen I think Nigella (or Giada) I think "sexy woman who cooks on TV". I suspect most people do too. If he had wanted to suggest "food and SCIENCE", there would be fewer people better suited to this suggestion than Alton Brown, at least in the US. I don't know if he's popular in the UK, but his Good Eats show presented a great mashup of popular science and cooking.