4 ms·
So what you are saying, is there is a hierarchy of hierarchies. Westerners suppress non-westerners. Within western society, whites suppress non-whites. And with
by runarberg 13y ago
So what you are saying, is there is a hierarchy of hierarchies. Westerners suppress non-westerners. Within western society, whites suppress non-whites. And within white westerners, the upper-class suppresses lower classes. And within the white- upper-class western society, males suppress females... One can continue.
Perhaps there is a tradition of suppression, starting at the bottom and reaching the top. I mean, women are suppressed within all classes, all societies, all races. (Generally speaking of course). Perhaps any kind of repression breeds further repression?
My point is. There is no need to stop focusing on systematic suppression on one group, just because other groups are also being suppressed.
EDIT: Before anybody comments on this, I know this presented hierarchy doesn't exist. I mean, I could as well have started with, "males suppress females, and within male society western males suppress..." (so there is more like a heap of hierarchies). I just used this as an example to make a point.
- rmc 13y agoYep. This is called "intersectionality". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality
- runarberg 13y agoSometimes I hear animal right activists argue that there is a direct link between animal oppression and minority oppression. I think they might not be far off. If you have the heart to oppress non-human animals, what's stopping you from oppressing the homeless, and if you have the hart to oppress the homeless, why do immigrants deserve your respect? why do the gays, why do women? I hadn't heard about intersectionality before, but knowing how dynamic the societal hierarchy is, and knowing that individuals are often times worse oppressors then governments, it makes sense that people would cast their oppression in various ways down the hierarchy.
- rmc 13y ago> Sometimes I hear animal right activists... Yep, some vegetarians claim that people who claim to be feminist should be vegetarian. Me? I'm a speciesist. > it makes sense that people would cast their oppression in various ways down the hierarchy. It's not always linear. A black man might be margalized in the work place (or the criminal justice system), but in a position of power at home over his wife, but if he is in prison, he might be in a position of power. "It's complicated" is a term commonly used by people within the social justice scene. And just because there are loads of systematice oppressions doesn't mean we can't fight them all and try to end them all. Classism and sexism and homophobia and ... are all wrong.
- nawitus 13y ago>My point is. There is no need to stop focusing on systematic suppression on one group, just because other groups are also being suppressed. My point is that we need to also focus on the systematic suppression of one group. For example, the minority gender in my country still has to do forced labour, and nobody seems to care because the focus is on women.
- runarberg 13y agoPoint taken. It's just that the article in question is focusing on a particular kind of suppression. I too live in a country where ageism and xenophobia attribute far more alienation and oppressive behaviour then sexism. But oppression is oppression, and whenever somebody is oppressed, it is worth fighting against, be it general, like you want to fight against, or specific, like this article is fighting against.