4 ms·
I agree. Even as an opinion, it was probably wrong for the majority of men. Whistling doesn't "reduce" the woman to just a sexual object, it just points out tha
by tomp 13y ago
I agree. Even as an opinion, it was probably wrong for the majority of men. Whistling doesn't "reduce" the woman to just a sexual object, it just points out that she is also a sexual object. I think a woman can be both beautiful and smart (and I think most men-loving persons would say the same for men), claiming otherwise seems plain ridiculous to me.
- pc86 13y agoHow about we not treat women as objects at all?
- brazzy 13y agoHow about you unambiguously define what it means to treat women as objects?
- runarberg 13y agoThat is treat a human being like she does not have emotions. That is treat a human being like something that is an object. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/objectification http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/objectification
- brazzy 13y ago> That is treat a human being like she does not have emotions. Why exactly do wolf whistles fall under this definition? > That is treat a human being like something that is an object. > http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/objectification http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/objectification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_definition
- runarberg 13y agoFirst, if you define women under the same criteria as objects, then you need to seriously reconsider your vocabulary. The world is different then Java™ will have you believe. In everyday language I talk about objects in terms of things that are not subjects. Subjects are characters --people and non-human animals-- that I attribute personality to, and can identify with. Objects are things that are not subjects. To objectify someone is, by definition, to treat a subject like an object. Heckling and wolf whistling is removing the characteristic of emotions from a subject. It is therefor treating a human being like an object. And, by definition objectifying.
- brazzy 13y ago> Heckling and wolf whistling is removing the characteristic of emotions from a subject. This is the only part of your statement that is not circular definition. And it is an unfounded assertion.
- runarberg 13y agoCan you explain where the definition gets circular so I can fix it, I'm sorry, but I can't find it. 1. An object is something that is not a subject. 2. A subject is a character, something I can identify with, something I can attribute some characteristic to. 3. To objectify is to remove from a subject the characteristics that makes it a subject.
- brazzy 13y agoOk, that's better now. What seemed circular to me was probably just redundancy. The core point is now: what are the characteristics that subjects have and objects don't? You have mentioned personality, identifiability and emotions. I'd add to that, even more central: free will (motivations and goals). Which brings us back to my original question: why/how do wolf whistles remove any of these (which?) from women?
- theorique 13y agoIf she presents a Public interface with accessible methods and attributes.
- antimagic 13y agoAnd do you think that an intelligent woman is going to appreciate being wolf-whistled? (hint: she doesn't).
- brazzy 13y agoHow many have you asked? This one disagrees with you: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/features/3636135/Why-women-like-being-wolf-whistled-at.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/features/3636135/Why-women-l...
- tptacek 13y agoThis is the dumbest thing I'll read all day.
- antimagic 13y agoOh, I bow before the philosophical might of a Telegraph article :/ As a female engineer, with lots of female friends that are lawyers, doctors, architects etc, I don't know a single one that appreciates being wolf-whistled in a professional context. Actually, we don't even appreciate it in a non-professional context. It usually generates a certain unease about physical safety, but at least in a non-professional context you can roll your eyes and attribute it to the fact that you're dealing with a neanderthal.
- brazzy 13y ago> Oh, I bow before the philosophical might of a Telegraph article :/ I'd love to read a randomized survey, but in principle, a single counterexample invalidates a general claim. > I don't know a single one that appreciates being wolf-whistled in a professional context. Have you actually discussed this with all of them? > It usually generates a certain unease about physical safety Why? Because of the stereotypes that go with it? Would a stranger walking up to you and telling you that you're sexy be more acceptable or less? What if they said beautiful instead? Or is it that you (your friends? all women?) generally don't want men to show their interest in you unless you first have given your premission in some subtle way? It seems to me that all of this is stuff is way too individually different to make such broad, sweeping statements. Heck, it probably is different for the same person depending on what mood they're in.