9 ms·
‘Record IQ is just another talent’ (2010)
- rational_indian 13y ago>having a high IQ is just another element of human talent. If there is a long spectrum of categories with many different talents, I would only be a part of the spectrum. I think this is spot on. Plus the scope of IQ tests seems to be limited to a very small part of the intelligence spectrum forget about assessing talent in general.
- jrs99 13y agoit's like quitting pro football. There are some people that think you're crazy, because they can't understand another mind that doesn't want to play pro football and throw a ball around professionally.
- majormajor 13y agoReminds me a bit of this from just a couple of months ago, about a guy who quit pro baseball because he didn't enjoy doing it as a business. Just because other people think you have to use a talent in a certain way doesn't mean that's what's best for you. "I quit because baseball was sacred to me until I started getting paid for it. The more that “baseball” became synonymous with “business,” the less it meant to me, and I saw less of myself in the game every time I got a check from the Philadelphia Phillies Organization, the Oakland Athletic Company, or the Chicago Cubs, L.L.C. To put it simply, other players were much better than I was at separating the game of baseball from the job of baseball." http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/sportingscene/2013/10/why-i-quit-major-league-baseball.html http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/sportingscene/2013/10/...
- talles 13y agoI often see this happening... with programming.
- thenerdfiles 13y agoAs "talent" might imply, indeed. Social expectations ruin everything because everyone disagrees on the details.
- salemh 13y agoThe headline is rather murky on the subject matters. It is a easy article on intelligence (light), expectations and happiness (heavy). From the article's introduction: What will people think of 16-month-old wonder child Jonathon Rader, able to play various musical instruments, if he decides not to pursue a career as a musician? ... “I was famous for having a 210 IQ and being able to solve intricate math equations at the age of four,” Kim said, adding, “Apparently, the media belittled the fact that I chose to work in a business planning department at Chungbuk Development Corporation.” Kim says the media denounced him as a “failed Genius” but he has no idea why his life, which he considers a success, had to be called a failure.
- interstitial 13y agoI'm always unimpressed with how these geniuses can solve all the math problems posed to them in these hagiographies (whether Bill Gates or the flavor of the month). Every math book past sophomore level is full of unsolved problems that have bested the brightest minds for centuries or longer. I'm always curious just how do these geniuses define a math problem?
- salemh 13y agoWhy is the problem being denigrated or juxtaposed or, broken down into syntax "math" important?
- gopalv 13y agoI feel for this guy - people can't understand that what he wants is "Life his way" and not to be a martyr to society burning his happiness to solve up equations. The greater good and so forth. But there is a fundamental angle that I find odd about people's perception of intelligence. People expect intelligence to be always found alongside ambition. When I watched "Limitless", it did hit me in an odd way. If I suddenly could out-think 99% of humanity, I wouldn't be running for president or becoming a stock trader profiting off the market. Actually, I don't know because I'm not that intelligent - but is that kind of ambition pasted over by Hollywood on top of intelligence? In comparison, everything from Thor, Dark Knight, Iron Man and even the new Wall Street movie was about clean power - hell, even Inception has got the guy with the windmills. That I felt like was an ambition that could occur with genius (i.e "First thing you do, is find the biggest problem on your planet and beat it"). But government official or company executive? That feels odd.
- derefr 13y ago> People expect intelligence to be always found alongside ambition. The amusing thing is, ambition is seen as more "inherent" than intelligence--part of your personality, rather than just a skill--and yet, improving general intelligence (by more than 5-10 IQ points) is nearly impossible, while improving ambition just requires taking some dopamine agonists. I would think it would be rational, given extremely high intelligence, to self-modify toward larger ambitions. I mean, if the ambitions you have are basically cached thoughts that stick around due mostly to inertia, from the limits you were unable to surmount while you were younger and had fewer resources... then why not challenge them? Ask yourself what you'd truly want, if you had every tool available? In fact, why not ask that now? Of course, the answer you arrive at, after this self-awareness comes, can still be an ambition that's limited in scope. But it'll be limited by choice by your current self, rather than imposed on you by your limited past self.
- darkmighty 13y agoYou're probably saying that as an ambitious man -- but happiness is not necessarily linked to "ambitious success". In fact, the opposite is likely -- if you're highly intelligent and have low ambition, it's very likely you will achieve whatever you're aiming for and lead a happy life. I say that as an ambitious person (I can't really understand "safe" people motivations either) - it's outside our capability to understand by ourselves a completely orthogonal mindset because you basically can't really simulate it to reach conclusions.
- danielharan 13y agoShocking: a smart person not willing to use the measure of success created by people that aren't as smart.
- Ygg2 13y agoReminds me of this quote from Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy: "For instance, on the planet Earth, man had always assumed that he was more intelligent than dolphins because he had achieved so much — the wheel, New York, wars and so on—whilst all the dolphins had ever done was muck about in the water having a good time. But conversely, the dolphins had always believed that they were far more intelligent than man—for precisely the same reasons."
- acchow 13y ago> When Kim decided to leave NASA [...] he wanted to get a job in Korea but to even do that he was told that he needed elementary, middle, and high school diplomas. “Since I had no official diploma ― I had to start all over from scratch,” Kim explained. Highest IQ in the world, 10 years of experience at NASA, and he wasn't drowning in job offers? South Korean companies need to think seriously about what they're looking for in an employee.
- girvo 13y agoSouth Korea's business culture is... Different, in my limited (lived there for 6mths and have a number of good friends from SK) experience, but also I think a lot of businesses wouldn't know what to do with someone so smart?
- acchow 13y ago> but also I think a lot of businesses wouldn't know what to do with someone so smart? Figuring out what to do with him wasn't what was holding them back. He got a job offer after completing his high school and college degree.
- xerophtye 13y agowell maybe it helped the companies figure out what to do with him. He did a business major so they put him in business dev.
- NovaS1X 13y agoThis type of thinking is the most frustrating thing I've ever encountered. Being held back by bureaucracy and HR filters has hurt more than a few highly-intelligent people. It's so incredibly demoralizing to be held back by inadequacy's of an education system or socioeconomic status.
- wellboy 13y agoI always wonder why super intelligent people like him don't start their own NASA or similar, but keep working for somebody.
- jey 13y agoSeems that having a more free/playful upbringing would have allowed him to explore his interests more. Being turned into an equation-solving robot seems to have crushed his soul.
- xerophtye 13y agoyeah, y the heck hire him when he was a kid? Why not let him be a kid? perhaps he actually would have done big things if you'd let him decide for himself. NOt that i am saying that what he decided to do with his life isnt that great
- xerophtye 13y agoImagine.... at age 7, surrounded by old people. of COURSE he was lonely! What did you expect? Now if he had a childhood, and entered NASA at the proper age, he might have even enjoyed it
- walshemj 13y agoWell at least he made it out the other side in one piece look at what happened to Micheal Jackson who didn't have a normal childhood
- smrtinsert 13y agoGood for him. If only every list brilliant person could re-center and take back their lives. I've seen too many bright stars burn out and fade away and not realize why.
- bane 13y agoUltra-intelligence reminds me of a conversation I had with friends years ago about super humanity -- probably after a night of drinking and too much sci-fi about genetically engineered superior humans. We decided that a person capable of at least 10% above human maximum (or human average, I can't really remember) in at least two or three areas or 25% in one would count as "Super human". This excludes most hyper-specializers like Olympic Sprinters, or professional chess players. Here's a fun video of the kind of deltas we were thinking of with professional American football players http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8tYqT9GDd8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8tYqT9GDd8 10% isn't all that much, but we felt like a person who could run an under 9 second 100 meter and had an Eidetic memory for example, would qualify as a classic super human. But IQ, IQ was hard. We couldn't decide about IQ. IQ is normalized at 100, fussy to test, and has questionable meaning. But suspending all those questions for a bit, given an "average" IQ of 100, a 10% or even 25% delta isn't really all that impressive at 110 or 125, not even Mensa levels. But let's take the top .1% of IQ, around 145, a 10% increase there is about 160 and a 25% increase is just north of 180 and now we're talking. Kim Ung-yong definitely qualifies as a single ability super human. Somebody with an IQ >160 should qualify for certain. After all a 60 point delta from mean the other way leaves you with an IQ of 40 and we're talking about pretty severe disability. So somebody who could run a sub-9 second 100 meter and had an IQ of say...170 would be super human by this completely arbitrary thinking. In the comics, people with these kinds of abilities, even as limited as this definition suggests, wear oddball costumes with the underwear on the outside and capes and either try to take over the world or try to save it. But in the real world, what people with abilities even close to these kinds of metrics end up doing is decidedly banal and often somewhat narcissistic. Fast runners just...run fast against other fast runners...they don't generally patrol cities and run down purse snatchers like the flash. Heavy lifters see who can lift the heaviest thing, they don't generally crack open burning buildings and fight thugs saving orphans like the Thing. People with both talents get organized into groups and end up seeing who can move a ball towards one end of a field over another. The really clever ones will parlay their fame into side businesses and open a burger restaurant or a theme bar or a line of sports oriented active wear. These folks aren't curing cancer, or stopping Fascism, or ending poverty, or worse, even trying to take over a moderate sized piece of real-estate and become Emperor of the Bronx or something. For the super smart, there's definitely work for them to do, but it's pretty limited stuff and you really have to like physics or math to do it. And let's be honest, Mensa and Mega aren't exactly wowing the world with a prolific output of revolutionary world changing ideas. I think partially because it's hard to go off and do the kinds of fantastic exceptional things that the general populace thinks you could do if you were super powered. Running a little bit faster still doesn't absolve you vigilante laws, but it can get you a Gold medal and some cereal advertising deals. Being ultra-smart doesn't mean you don't have to deal with averagely smart people to get anything more complex than tinkering done. Nobody so far is so smart than they can hack their way through the rest of dim-witted humanity like Ozymandias from the Watchmen. History has shown that people with exceptional intelligence (at least as measured by IQ) also go on to do rather hum-drum things. - Marilyn vos Savant writes a 2 inch high weekly column where she gives advice and helps people solve Supermarket brain teasers and Freshman probability problems. - Scott Adams created a mildly observant comic strip about working in a professional office environment - Asia Carrera made a career of getting filmed while having sex and playing videogames - and on and on, a look at some lists of known ultra-IQ folks shows a list of comedians, some more porn actresses and models, actors, some pro-wrestlers, a bunch of fiction writers etc. There's very, painfully, few people who occupied their time with something that really moved humanity up a notch and even most of those are debatable. Hell, HN is full of people who I'd guess are in the 90+ percentile and most of what we do here is pontificate and build chat apps so people can share pictures of their cats.
- tzs 13y agoRelevant song: http://www.broadjam.com/artists/songs.php?artistID=35045&mediaID=271694&play=true http://www.broadjam.com/artists/songs.php?artistID=35045&med...
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoI suspect HN and r/programming have a lot of high IQ members who aren't doing much with their lives.
- asdfologist 13y agoTrue, minus the high IQ part.
- chroma 13y agoI realize this sentiment won't be popular, but I feel it must be said: I'm glad he's happy, but it's sad that this man didn't live up to his potential. There is an unimaginable amount of suffering in this world. Around 150,000 people die each day. About 5 million children die each year. Millions of people are maimed or killed by accident, disease, and violence. Considering this man's talents, I would much rather live in a world where he devoted himself to solving important problems. I realize he wouldn't be as happy, but the expected value in lives saved is quite high. Before anyone accuses me of hypocrisy: I follow my own advice. I've chosen a career geared toward maximizing my benefit to others, not my own happiness. This quote from Circular Altruism[1] reflects my views: You know what? This isn't about your feelings. A human life, with all its joys and all its pains, adding up over the course of decades, is worth far more than your brain's feelings of comfort or discomfort with a plan. Does computing the expected utility feel too cold-blooded for your taste? Well, that feeling isn't even a feather in the scales, when a life is at stake. Just shut up and multiply. If enough people choose to do this, who knows what might happen? Maybe one day humanity will have its shit together. 1. http://lesswrong.com/lw/n3/circular_altruism/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/n3/circular_altruism/
- qt31415926 13y agoGiven his upbringing, I would say he never had the potential in the first place. From how he talks about his time at NASA, it seems like he was used as an equation-solving tool 10 years. “At that time, I led my life like a machine ― I woke up, solved the daily assigned equation, ate, slept, and so forth. I really didn’t know what I was doing, and I was lonely and had no friends,” His choices now are the result of how NASA as an institution treated him. Having the highest IQ is great for problem solving. But why should he empathize with the problems of the world when no one did the same for him?
- dan00 13y ago> There is an unimaginable amount of suffering in this world. Around 150,000 people die each day. About 5 million children die each year. Millions of people are maimed or killed by accident, disease, and violence. Considering this man's talents, I would much rather live in a world where he devoted himself to solving important problems. I realize he wouldn't be as happy, but the expected value in lives saved is quite high. Most human suffering isn't just solved by smart people thinking hard about solving some problems. Most human suffering is caused by missing compassion for people. > I've chosen a career geared toward maximizing my benefit to others, not my own happiness. Sorry, but I don't think that's the case. You're doing what you do, because it feels right for you, so in a way you can't get happier by doing something else. You might not follow the hedonistic path, but you're still doing what makes you most happy.
- jib 13y agoI think the article makes a true point well. Intelligence of the type that is approximated by IQ (pattern identification, relationship modeling and whatnot) is like most things just another ability. It's a useful ability in that you can use it to mimic some other useful abilities if you so choose, but it is just another ability. Any implications of it being something else is just outside expectation applied by people who want to further their own agenda, goals, world view or values etc. Expecting someone with that type of intelligence to conform to any specific set of values or goals is like expecting someone who is tall to conform to the idea of being a sports star etc.
- evunveot 13y agoHN commenters in general seem to be fairly dismissive when discussions about IQ come up. (I imagine it comes from a place of humility, because many people here know that they personally have high IQs.) I thought I understood what an IQ was (it seems like a simple concept), but that was before a friend started a graduate-level school psychology program. If you want to see how complex it is, start here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_%28psychometrics%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_%28psychometrics%29 If you're interested in the math, it's all about this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factor_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factor_analysis In simplified and imprecise terms, your IQ is a statistical construct, i.e. not something that can be observed or measured directly, but an imagined variable that (by definition) correlates with a bunch of things that can be measured. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_stratum_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_stratum_theory Popular culture fixates on people with very high IQs, but the real importance of intelligence testing in society is identifying people who qualify for interventions or benefits due to low intelligence, usually IQ < 70 (two standard deviations below the mean). There are literally regulations in some jurisdictions that basically say "If you can produce an IQ score of 69 you qualify for X, Y and Z; if you score a 71 you qualify for nothing." Just saying: IQ is definitely fuzzy, but it's not meaningless or just a measure of how good you are at puzzles. Intelligence testing involves actual science and has real stakes in society.
- tokenadult 13y agoI missed this thread till just now. I wish I had jumped in earlier. The man from Korea profiled in the article recounts, "I was famous for having a 210 IQ," and that's what generated all the publicity. But in fact, an IQ score that high could not possibly be a validated IQ score from a currently normed test. There must have been some mistake in administering or scoring the test, back in the day, and the same is true of any other report you have ever seen of an IQ score above 200. (No IQ score above 200 is a validated, currently normed score comparable to other IQ scores. Not one, not any. Scores above 200 are bogus, at least insofar as they purport to be comparable to the scores from IQ tests that most people hear about.) Let's see which Wikipedia articles have been revised to fight the myths about high IQ scores, and which merely perpetuate them. Let's see, "High IQ society"[1] correctly reports that "The highest reported standard score for most IQ tests is IQ 160, approximately the 99.997th percentile (leaving aside the issue of the considerable error in measurement at that level of IQ on any IQ test).[2] IQ scores above this level are dubious as there are insufficient normative cases upon which to base a statistically justified rank-ordering.[3][4] High IQ scores are less reliable than IQ scores nearer to the population median.[5]" all of which is true. I can remember when that article was much more misleading about how IQ scores work. The Wikipedia article "Marilyn vos Savant"[2] correctly reports "Alan S. Kaufman, a psychology professor and author of IQ tests, writes in IQ Testing 101 that "Miss Savant was given an old version of the Stanford-Binet (Terman & Merrill 1937), which did, indeed, use the antiquated formula of MA/CA × 100. But in the test manual's norms, the Binet does not permit IQs to rise above 170 at any age, child or adult. And the authors of the old Binet stated: 'Beyond fifteen the mental ages are entirely artificial and are to be thought of as simply numerical scores.' (Terman & Merrill 1937). ...the psychologist who came up with an IQ of 228 committed an extrapolation of a misconception, thereby violating almost every rule imaginable concerning the meaning of IQs."[12] "The second test reported by Guinness was Hoeflin's Mega Test, taken in the mid-1980s. The Mega Test yields IQ standard scores obtained by multiplying the subject's normalized z-score, or the rarity of the raw test score, by a constant standard deviation, and adding the product to 100, with Savant's raw score reported by Hoeflin to be 46 out of a possible 48, with a 5.4 z-score, and a standard deviation of 16, arriving at a 186 IQ. The Mega Test has been criticized by professional psychologists as improperly designed and scored, "nothing short of number pulverization."[13]" But, yeah, if we get beyond the premise that the man in Korea ever had such a high IQ score (he may have been told the number, but the person who told him made some kind of mistake), then we can reflect on the issue of what we expect from children after they are told they have high IQ scores. Is it a failure simply to make an honest living and take care of a family? I think not. Very high IQ or moderately high IQ, the path to genius also involves a lot of hard work, opportunity, and not a little luck.[3] I think the man profiled in the article has done just fine and has nothing to be ashamed of. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_IQ_society#Entry_requirements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_IQ_society#Entry_requirem... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_vos_Savant#Rise_to_fame_and_IQ_score https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_vos_Savant#Rise_to_fam... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genius#IQ_and_genius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genius#IQ_and_genius