4 ms·
Artist here. Okay. Working out perspective by hand is hard. It's a lot of work, that takes a lot of arcane knowledge. So's doing a photorealistic painting of
by egypturnash 13y ago
Artist here.
Okay. Working out perspective by hand is hard. It's a lot of work, that takes a lot of arcane knowledge.
So's doing a photorealistic painting of a thing. You have to look at the thing, consider a bunch of relationships of the particular feature you're interested in at this very moment, and transfer those relationships to your canvas. That's a pretty complicated set of habits and brain circuitry you have to build up over a period of years.
Tracing an image is immensely easier. There's all the perspective, there's all the proportion relationships. There's all the colors. Right there in front of you. You can spend an hour or two essentially doing manual edge-detection, and then start filling in areas.
There's still stuff to learn - how to mix the paint to get the colors you want, how to apply it to the canvas, stuff like that. And if you trace organic stuff too closely, it starts to look stiff and dead. But compared to the amount of skill you have to learn to draw this kind of stuff out of your head? It's nothing.
I mean, hell. Take a photo, print it out. Tape it to a sunny window, tape another piece of paper over it, and trace it. Then take that same photo and try to draw a copy of it, without tracing. There will be a huge difference between the two drawings you just made. The one made without tracing will probably have taken a lot longer, and have many more bits erased and redrawn.
A lot of modern artists have this weird thing going on with respect to tracing. It's the worst thing ever, they'll say. Tracing another person's work to learn from, or tracing off of a photo, they're different kinds of art crimes, but they're still art crimes. Leaping around learning to break a scene down in your head and reconstruct it from scratch - essentially building a wetware 3D modeller in your brain, really - is considered CHEATING by some people.
So Hockney's book on Vermeer's work is essentially saying "dude Vermeer was totally a tracer". Which in many artist's eyes is like calling him Not An Artist. Artists get weird about what is Art and what is Not Art, it's this whole thing that's about as inexplicable to a layperson as a programmer's choice of text editor.
By using mirrors and lenses to project an image onto his camera to trace, Vermeer only had to learn the basic painting technique stuff. If he did, if he traced all this stuff, then some people will start saying that his work is no longer Art. It's just Illustration. Which, in the eyes of people who care about this, means that it is a lower, less respectable thing. Now it's just a filter applied to an image, albiet manually instead of via Photoshop or whatever.
The truth of the matter (IMHO) is that a lot of the people who will scream bloody murder when someone is tracing are amateurs. Real pros can and will project images and work over them, build reference models in the real world or in 3D programs, and do any damn thing they can to make the hard parts of their work easier, to get all those little details they'd never make up out of whole cloth.
I am pretty sure I've repeated myself a couple times here, thanks to the tiny window HN allows to type in. But hopefully this helps.
tl;dr: If Vermeer used these techniques then he's a dirty cheating TRACER and is thus not a REAL ARTIST in some people's eyes.
- andrewliebchen 13y agoIt doesn't make Vermeer any less of an artistic genius. He had to invent new or improve existing devices, set up the scene, not to mention execute the painting itself. No one says photo-realistic painters are fakers or cheaters when they recreate photographs on the canvas. Working from a photo does a lot of the same work as a camera obscura; it flattens the perspective, defines the colors, etc.
- wrongc0ntinent 13y agoegypturnash isn't endorsing what you're opposing here.
- wrongc0ntinent 13y ago"Modern" in the art context has a time period attached to it (20th century), you're looking for "contemporary" most likely.
- egypturnash 13y agoIMHO it's time to stop using "modern" as the tag for the art of the late twentieth century and find a new name - but yes. n.n
- panacea 13y ago>I am pretty sure I've repeated myself a couple times here, thanks to the tiny window HN allows to type in. Insightful comment... sorry to only directly reference this line, but you can expand the text field by using the drag-handle in the lower-right.
- egypturnash 13y agoFor some weird reason it wasn't working for me when I wrote that comment.
- mtts 13y agoOccasional amateur painter here. Yes, tracing images is immensely easier. Problem is it yields lousy paintings. Photographs have different perspective and lighting than what you see with your own eyes and paintings that have been made by tracing or even merely copying photographs almost always look, well, like someone smeared paint all over a photograph. If you look at a Vermeer painting, you'll find it does not look photographic at all. The objects in the picture are almost tangible and seem to jump off the canvas. This is an effect that is only achievable by having very strong 3D skills: you basically have to be able to paint even more realistically than mere realism. So it might very well be that Vermeer used some tools to get a feel for what it was he was going to paint and maybe even to study the fleeting effects of lighting, but the final paintings themselves are without a doubt made by someone with exceptional skill. TL;DR;Vermeer did not use these techniques because his paintings are way better than what can be achieved using only these techniques.