4 ms·
and that an engineer that has so little empathy as to not understand why the use of gendered pronouns is a concern almost certainly makes poor technical decisio
by mindcrime 13y ago
and that an engineer that has so little empathy as to not understand why the use of gendered pronouns is a concern almost certainly makes poor technical decisions as well.
Uuuuh, yeah, except for the little bit about the English language having notoriously poor support for gender neutral pronouns in the first place. TBH, blindly substituting "them" and "they" everywhere will result in sentences that are incorrect. It doesn't take a huge lack of empathy to suggest that it's better to write in a way that's grammatically correct while asking people to accept either:
a. the generic use of "he" OR "she" as a universal singular pronon
or
b. randomly switching between the two throughout the document as way of indicating inclusiveness.
- VonGuard 13y agob is awesome. White Wolf books used to use "she" everywhere, too. Write a script to change it every month.
- matdesigner 13y agoexcept women and men aren't the only genders in tech/the english language, and just switching between "he" and "she" is still non-inclusive of them.
- Tohhou 13y agoThere are human genders other than male and female? Scientific or imaginary?
- gruntmaster9000 13y agoGender != sex.
- Tohhou 13y agoGender is the grammar layer above sex. Sex informs gender. Gender is not a purely social construct out of nowhere. In English, there is the ternary, but it is defined as without the male/female. People generally don't like being called it though. Even if they have a special snowflake prounoun such as xer which they prefer the rest of the world can't know this and so it is fair and reasonable to call them what they look like they most identify out of the binary. Or we can just stop using pronouns altogether, even in industries largely of men, because we wouldn't want to make it seem like women can't take part in them (even when there is nothing stopping them). I'd be fine with that. Men don't exist anyway. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZAuqkqxk9A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZAuqkqxk9A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grammatical_gender http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grammatical_gender
- gruntmaster9000 13y agoYou are confusing grammatical gender with gender identity. It is also informed by sex, but that is only one influence.
- Tohhou 13y ago>It is also informed by sex, but that is only one influence. Right, so it's not fair to say that gender != sex when gender is the grammatical expression of a sex within an environment's constraints. >You are confusing grammatical gender with gender identity. The grammar is the expression of masculine and feminine, which vary based on constraints, but still stick to the sexual binary. Going beyond that is special snowflake territory where people invent their own thing to be unique while expecting to be taken seriously. Complaining that people don't use your preferred pronoun is a perfect case for first world problems. My original comment you replied to "There are human genders other than male and female? Scientific or imaginary?" All else other than male (primary masculine) and female (primary feminine) are imaginary, and not based on biological reality. Those things do not merit being taken seriously no more than any religion or superstition. Male and female based sexes will always be re-expressed in very similar ways, as they have all over the world in varying civilizations, while others will never be the same. I'ts the same as religions or ideologies. It is complete fabrication of the mind. If people want to invent new identities fine, but white washing away him and her so that all of the other newly minted pronouns don't feel left out is ridiculous. >Hi, I'm Caramelkh. I'm demisexual, polyromantic, fat positive genderqueer (neutrois, femme presenting), sexual assault survivor (7 times), native American, Muslim neuroatypical with OCD, cotard delusion, trimethylaminuria, social phobias, depression, post traumatic stress, anxiety issues and I can't walk very far. On my blog I will NOT tolerate any form of oppressive bullshit language and I will not hesitate to call you out on it. My preferred pronouns are ze/zy/zo/zum. After reading my about me section above, you still know nothing about me other than that the long list of labels means I get to have experienced nearly every type of kyriarchy oppression and so I can call people out on anything and say it triggers and offends me. If people get bored, I invent new oppressions. I'm triggered by the color teal. Or better yet the new thing of people insisting to be called only by the pronoun brony.
- rsynnott 13y ago> TBH, blindly substituting "them" and "they" everywhere will result in sentences that are incorrect If done blindly, potentially. If done properly, no. Modern tech writing tends to use singular they anyway. > It doesn't take a huge lack of empathy to suggest that it's better to write in a way that's grammatically correct Singular they is not incorrect.