3 ms·
> the problem is that it's always the other guy or some corporation who's being unfair Self-interest doesn't make someone incorrect. Isn't that one of the tene
by jjoonathan 13y ago
> the problem is that it's always the other guy or some corporation who's being unfair
Self-interest doesn't make someone incorrect. Isn't that one of the tenets of libertarianism? Also, it's not like the free market is some kind of objective tie-breaker. Outcomes in a market are highly sensitive to regulatory conditions. Before you suggest doing away with as many regulations as possible, consider that "regulatory conditions" can include things as basic as the definition of property, which is a problem that cannot be dodged in even the most libertarian of societies. Does society have a notion of intellectual property? If not, how do you propose to fund drug development? Can infrastructure be privately owned? If so, how do you stop natural monopolies from destroying competition? Should a company be allowed to buy up property surrounding your house and then ransom travel through their property off for all you are worth plus all you can borrow? The list goes on.
> I'd say it is completely unfair that a government takes a portion of my income
Whoa, there! You're assuming what you set out to prove: that the government's slice was yours to begin with. The social contract comes as a bundle deal. You "sign away" your tax dollars by being part of a society that provides services to you. Obviously no explicit consent is involved, but that's because it can't be involved. Voting is the best compromise we've been able to come up with.
Even in a libertarian society, government provides one very important service that disproportionately benefits the rich: enforcement of property law.
> Are people in the government somehow know the ultimate truth?
No, the existence of government is a compromise between a free market that has flaws and a system of absolute control that also has flaws. We delegate responsibility for the areas where one system is hopelessly flawed to the other system (which merely has to do a better job, not a flawless job). Adam Smith himself acknowledged that the free market is not suited to provide certain services (police, infrastructure, military, etc). The goverment isn't aware of any "ultimate truth" here, but they aren't going to pull the whole "box you in and take all your money" stunt either.
- snitko 13y agoThe are plenty of ideas and solutions that answer your questions. I wouldn't like to repeat them now as it happens in every thread when I mention some libertarian ideas. I think the important thing to understand is that a government is not some magic cure for all the problems you mentioned. If you take a simple idea that a government is a monopoly on almost all of the things that it does, then you can go from here. Monopolies are mostly not good for consumers; and a huge one with an access to an unlimited force is certainly not.
- jjoonathan 13y ago> I wouldn't like to repeat them now as it happens in every thread when I mention some libertarian ideas. Funny, I feel like the whole "free market knows best" idea pops up in every thread even though I have no trouble providing counterexamples. I'm genuinely curious to see how you would solve the problems I brought up, especially the ones surrounding the subjectivity of property law. > the important thing to understand is that a government is not some magic cure for all the problems you mentioned I'm pretty sure my post said precisely that. We agree on this point; no need to belabor it. My statement amounts to the trivial counterpart regarding free markets, but I'm pretty sure you don't actually think free markets are perfect (or even always a better option), so how about we continue on to the part where we discuss specifics? > Monopolies are mostly not good for consumers; and a huge one with an access to an unlimited force is certainly not. A monopoly without profit-maximizing incentives, universally shared ownership, and checks+balances (relatively speaking on both counts, of course) seems preferable to one with profit-maximizing incentives, without broad ownership, and without checks+balances. Especially when it comes to force.
- snitko 13y agoOk, let me tackle this one specific point first (I'll address others a bit later, as I have to leave now). > A monopoly without profit-maximizing incentives and with universally shared ownership (relatively speaking on both counts, of course) seems preferable Now, that's in theory. In practice, where are those angels who work in the government and don't seek profit for themselves? Where do you find those people who would be immune to lobbyists and always serve the people of the country? Because if you don't have a very precise workable procedure on how to elect such individuals and also the one that wouldn't allow them to become corrupt in the process, then you can't claim an existence of such a monopoly is better than its absence. Politics attracts people who like power and would willingly lie to and coerce the people who elected them. The only way I see is to deny such people opportunity to have this power. Free market may not be perfect, but it fosters virtue to a much greater degree than politics. A politician must first get power to do some good, while a businessmen must first do some good to make money.