4 ms·
I see the point here. Attempting to put legal dogs onto this type of issue does not at all cover the scope of how society's perception pans out. The fact that
by thenerdfiles 13y ago
I see the point here. Attempting to put legal dogs onto this type of issue does not at all cover the scope of how society's perception pans out.
The fact that a legal system might punish someone does not in any way demotivate the behavior but merely makes it more intractable when it does happen. That someone is punished doesn't change the motivations behind the victim's name change, and other efforts.
The question still stands, for companies or institutions of victims like this: Do we want to affiliate ourselves with someone who has a love life that cannot be respected[0], that is out of line with our organization's ethos?
Punishment does not at all address this cultural problem: What is porn ?
[0]: "But the presence of Hip as a working philosophy in the sub-worlds of American life is probably due to jazz, and its knife-like entrance into culture, its subtle but so penetrating influence on an avant-garde generation—that post-war generation of adventurers who (some consciously, some by osmosis) had absorbed the lessons of disillusionment and disgust of the Twenties, the Depression, and the War. Sharing a collective disbelief in the words of men who had too much money and controlled too many things, they knew almost as powerful a disbelief in the socially monolithic ideas of the single mate, the solid family and the respectable love life."
-- http://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/the-white-negro-fall-1957 http://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/the-white-neg...
- johnchristopher 13y ago> The question still stands, for companies or institutions of victims like this: Do we want to affiliate ourselves with someone who has a love life that cannot be respected[0], that is out of line with our organization's ethos? If you do not align with the victim in these 'revenge porn' cases then you reinforce the extortionist's position. Does that align with any organization's ethos ?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thenerdfiles 13y agoIt's not clear to me that the extortionist has a "position" or that it goes without saying that any organization who does not sympathize is at the same point aligning with the "revenge" sentiment. Incidents like this can happen without the "revenge" component. Bots and malware might do this. The organization believes it has PR to manage.
- thenerdfiles 13y agoSomething of substance to take away from the above: Revenge porn is not porn. Just because there's nudity, there's a woman, and it's a JPG on a website, that does not make it porn. Calling this hateful act "porn" is a misnomer, and throws a valid mode of both sexual and aesthetic as well as economic and political expression under the proverbial bus.