3 ms·
The problem with covering claims of changing paradigms is: who is qualified to evaluate such ambitious claims? Realistically, not many folks. I think the best
by snowwrestler 13y ago
The problem with covering claims of changing paradigms is: who is qualified to evaluate such ambitious claims? Realistically, not many folks.
I think the best thing for a reporter to do is to connect the appropriate experts together to build a balanced story. Yes, spend time with Wolfram, take good notes etc.--but then find the right experts to respond to and evaluate what he said.
To me, this story reads a bit too credulous to be really useful in understanding what Wolfram is claiming. I read Wolfram's blog post already, and this story seems about the same in tone and content.
What I want to see is the equivalant of this [1] article: a cranky review by an expert in the field...with citations.
[1] http://vserver1.cscs.lsa.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfram/ http://vserver1.cscs.lsa.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfra...
- Houshalter 13y agoIsn't that what hacker news comments are for?
- wrongc0ntinent 13y agoWolfram is a master at this game. You can't deny the brilliant stuff he's done; throw in new terminology for unoriginal concepts, and it becomes very hard to call a bluff (or a delusion). Edit: or confirm.
- nl 13y agoWolframAlpha (the current site/service) is pretty impressive as it stands now. It's good enough that I did the first few Project Euler[1] puzzles on it, and given that it isn't really a programming tool I think that's a decent demonstration. I'd be inclined to believe he has something new, that really can do things that are difficult with other tools. Whether or not it is useful is another question. [1] http://projecteuler.net/ http://projecteuler.net/