4 ms·
Fair enough. It sounds like your view could be described as a utilitarian value system that you impose after the fact based on a preconceived notion of some en
by grandalf 17y ago
Fair enough. It sounds like your view could be described as a utilitarian value system that you impose after the fact based on a preconceived notion of some ends you hope society will achieve.
You also seem to perceive that there exists a true greater good. I challenge you to introspect on that issue. I personally don't believe that the greater good really exists, and I attribute the creation of the meme to religious leaders who used their divine authority to declare what the greater good is so that the faithful would work to promote it in order to save their souls from eternal damnation -- notice the parallels with the modern secular notion?
More mathematically, every individual has a set of interests/preferences. You can consider a function that maps from possible choices (individual, state, etc.) to everyone's preferences and try to maximize the amount of utility generated. But the problem for planners is that sometimes what is in an individual's best interest is not actually what the person wants. So calculating the greater good involves myriad assumptions and fudges... and at its core any notion of the greater good involves making an aesthetic choice of how to transfer benefit/harm across some set of people.
For instance, any notion of the greater good applied to US politics probably neglects the harm inflicted on those who live just across the border who would be happy to work in the US but starve due to US immigration policies. Pretty soon the concept of the greater good (for any meaningful policy choice) conflicts with the idea of nationhood itself and becomes meaningless.
- mquander 17y agoI recognize upon reading your comment that it is really quite a cycle -- culture changes our opinion about what the greater good is, and then we all go and talk about how to reorganize the culture to get it! I'll think about this some more tonight.