3 ms·
This post is interesting on multiple levels. I'm an upper middle class white male, who has been a homeless drug addict living on welfare. Things are rarely as s
by girvo 13y ago
This post is interesting on multiple levels. I'm an upper middle class white male, who has been a homeless drug addict living on welfare. Things are rarely as simple as you make it out to be, though yes there are systemic problems that the current thinking doesn't seem to address nor fix. The thing is, the people you are talking about may have different priorities and choices in life to yourself.. Is that inherently a bad thing? I don't think so, and so I attempt to avoid generalising when it comes to this. A huge "work for the dole" plan rarely has the outcome that you'd logically assume it would. These are differences on a sub culture level. It's a huge topic and one that sociologists actively study because of that.
- bane 13y agoI disagree to some point. I think it's a very simple problem that we've made very complex; work or starve to death. This makes us, a modern civilized, post-enlightenment civilization very queasy, but people will do unbelievable amounts of very terrible work to make sure they have a full belly and mediocre shelter from the elements. > the people you are talking about may have different priorities and choices in life to yourself.. Is that inherently a bad thing? I don't think so, and so I attempt to avoid generalising when it comes to this. I agree, but not all prioritizations are beneficial ones. They don't have to be mine, but I do wish that everybody's personal prioritizations led them to be at lest economically self-sufficient if not beneficial for society. I think you nailed it on the head though. I have some very dear friends from when I grew up poor that are still poor...and the reason for it is inevitably the life choices they've made that have kept them in that state -- because they've prioritized and made important things that don't help them get out of it. (kudos on getting out of the bad state you were in, I'd love to know more of your story)
- onetwofiveten 13y agoWell it's still pretty complicated, because there's no option to go out and hunt for a living. You can't earn food without participating in society, which is a very complicated system of rules that few of us have any influence over (but a small minority have large influence over). Changing those rules to make them more in line with the idea "work or starve" would not be simple. (What about tax? Farming subsidies? What if someone gets a monopoly on the cheapest staple food in an area? What about genetically modified crop patents?) Also, if it became common to motivate people through starvation, life would quickly become quite terrible. (Just look at the things that used to happen during the industrial revolution. Dangerous child labour, terrible working conditions, lives and limbs sacrificed in the name of progress.) I'm glad we have idle people who don't want to work, because that way the guys in charge have to make sure that working is at least better than not working. In the not too distant future there won't be jobs for unremarkable people, and I don't really want them to starve.
- girvo 13y agoFunny, based on your first sentence, we actually agree! It is a simple problem, made complex by what we've "Built" around it... I just wish I had a good answer to it all :( I'm writing a book on my life at the moment, my email is in my profile if you'd like some more info :)