5 ms·
Based on communities with multi-generational welfarism, I'd suggest that idleness comes with pretty serious social problems. Employment imposes minimum pro-soci
by jacques_chester 13y ago
Based on communities with multi-generational welfarism, I'd suggest that idleness comes with pretty serious social problems. Employment imposes minimum pro-social requirements on the employee.
- gress 13y agoI don't see how there is any relationship at all between current implementations of welfare and a putative work-free society given that welfare is associated with low social position and limited access to resources for self betterment.
- jacques_chester 13y agoSo you consider it to be a cultural artefact? What about antisocial behaviour by those who've inherited high status?
- dreamfactory 13y agoYou mean spoilt kids behaving badly? You can be given material needs without having to work but you will still need to work hard to become a dancer, ride a skateboard, play the piano etc. Maybe the root problem leading to antisocial behaviour isn't financial but a lack of cultural values?
- gress 13y agoI think that is absolutely cultural too. I have lived in both environments. High status people or those born to riches are by no means universally antisocially behaved. I don't disagree that such people exist. Nor do I disagree that multigenerational, anti-social welfare recipients exist. Both groups exist I cultures where superficial media success and the acquisition of money are held up as the meaning of life. For the welfare recipients, this kind of meaning is perceived as impossibly out of reach, and so people are resentful and adopt a 'take what you can from the system' mentality. For some of the high status people, meaning is also unattainable since they already have what other people seem to value, so society doesn't value their actual contribution. In cultures where the 'rich' have a sense of responsibility, there is much less of the bad behavior you describe.
- bane 13y agoGrowing up near a major U.S. city with a very high percentage of multi-generational welfare recipients. The rampant idleness is one of the visible signs that actually makes me feel really upset. Driving to meetings and seeing a couple dozen very healthy guys in the middle of any given workday hanging around and harassing people because they're bored or, drinking themselves into a stupor just to kill another day where they do nothing and nothing happens, is a very serious problem. The parts of town where this happens are inevitably high crime, run down and dangerous. None of these people have to work as all of their basic needs are met. Any extra money they come across (usually by panhandling) doesn't get reported and is almost always used for either bullshit like "bling", drugs/booze or gambling. Very few have more than a cursory education and most dropped out of school as soon as they could stop getting truancy officers to stop sending them back. There's simply no reason to learn anything. Interacting with these folks is difficult even on basic conversational levels. There's an old saying, "the devil makes use of idle hands" and it has a lot of wisdom in it on many levels. I'm a very big proponent of large government work programs. Every one of these guys who I see every day would be better off earning their way by fixing up infrastructure in the U.S. or doing migrant farm work or something marginally productive for society. But instead they drag down entire sections of cities into such a state that even driving through their areas is a test of patience and risking your own safety.
- dnautics 13y agoWhat is going to happen when "one of these guys" refuses to sign up for your large government work program? Is the government going to enslave them in order to keep them from being idle? Is this going to be voluntary? Think about Fuller's quote - we have people making tools for inspectors to inspect people. What do you suppose is going to be the overhead for your massive make-work program? And what is going to be the environmental cost of this program? Who absorbs the externalities as the government tears up the environment in the name of employment? In other words, quis custodiet custodies?
- smm2000 13y agoif he refuses to work, he will stop getting money/benefits from the state. If he commits crimes to get money, he will be put in jail. After third crime he will get life sentence and he will not inconvinience society any more. Putting people in jail is expensive but I think society can afford it. Not much different from what we have know. Busywork can be totally environmenrally friendly. For example, manually sorting recycle and compost comes to mind.
- Gustomaximus 13y agoI think these social problem comes from idleness without opportunity. Also they are placed low in society in terms of possessions so feel an underclass. If these people cant afford to follow their interests or even travel across town because they don't have bus fare yes it's going to create problems. But what if all people have a similar base and while being on welfare have a reasonable level of disposable income to pursue hobbies? I don't know the answer but I suspect there would be a big outlook difference of US welfare recipients vs. Kuwait where welfare recipients have disposable income. Further it's easy to say there will be people causing social issues. This will always exist to a degree. We have to consider if this would be relatively better or worse for society, not just would there be problems.
- jacques_chester 13y ago> I don't know the answer but I suspect there would be a big outlook difference of US welfare recipients vs. Kuwait where welfare recipients have disposable income. I'm not familiar with the Kuwaiti experience, could you elaborate? > We have to consider if this would be relatively better or worse for society, not just would there be problems. Agreed; though I'm wary of making big, breaking changes to a complex, evolved system. Previous attempts to cut over to radically different socioeconomic architectures in production have tended to end poorly.
- vellum 13y agoI'm not familiar with the Kuwaiti experience, could you elaborate? Kuwait has enough oil money to give their people free health care, free education, housing subsidies, and food subsidies. On top of that, they have guaranteed employment so ~96% of their citizens work for the state. Oh, and there's no income tax. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/1192652.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspon...
- allochthon 13y agoThere might be other levers that can be used to encourage pro-social behavior than the current one, of chaining those not on welfare to the struggle for their existence. In my own view, financial autonomy is a basic right. We should seek out other, more dignified ways to discourage people from hanging out on street corners harassing people.
- jacques_chester 13y agoWhat did you have in mind?
- allochthon 13y agoI'm not sure. Perhaps people who are ticketed for anti-social behavior or who are picked up by the criminal justice system would need to do community service or face a gradual escalation of penalties -- not be able to own a credit card, hold a driver's license, etc.
- georgefox 13y agoI don't want to disagree with you, but I suspect there's more to this than just idle time. For example, there are plenty of retirement communities where idle time is the norm, and the social problems of poor urban American neighborhoods aren't really found there.
- jacques_chester 13y agoGood counterexample; though those in retirement homes are generally not from multi-generational welfare backgrounds. I'm not sure if I'm undermining my own argument here.
- dwaltrip 13y agoI'm simply spouting my random opinion here, but my guess is that the communities you point to suffer from non-ideal cultural-behavioral traditions that are passed down and ingrained into each new generation. If one is raised in a family/community where money is always an issue/stress point, parents are overworked, alcohol and shallow-content media are the main forms of entertainment, little encouragement for hobbies is provided, etc, then the odds are stacked against pursuing what many people might consider an intellectually-engaging or constructive lifestyle.
- ewoodrich 13y agoAssuming you're referring to the US (which you may not be), how is this "multi-generational welfarism" viable when benefits are restricted to a five-year lifetime cap after 1996? In addition, there is a work requirement while receiving welfare (welfare-to-work). Food stamps do not have such a limitation, but would hardly be able to support the long term lifestyle you describe.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI'm Australian. My understanding is that the effects of the Clinton reforms are somewhat disputed. I don't like the idea of time-limiting welfare based on arbitrary cap. It's a case of "fixing" the metric, not the problem.
- guelo 13y agoYou seem to have no idea how little to no money welfare actually provides to the poor in this country. People with your type of thinking have won the political debate over the last 30 years but things are not improving and people like you keep making the same uninformed arguments.