4 ms·
This essay completely misses Ayn Rand's point. Consider your life and the basic problem of deciding how to live it. Being "selfish" means living your life acc
by grandalf 17y ago
This essay completely misses Ayn Rand's point.
Consider your life and the basic problem of deciding how to live it.
Being "selfish" means living your life according to what is most meaningful to you. For some that means heading to Wall Street, for others it means being a doctor, and for others it means working at Burger King.
In modern terminology, Rand's term "selfish" should be substituted accurately with self-actualized. Her term "selfish" was actually chosen as a deliberate synonym for "self-actualized" that didn't sound like psychobabble.
Now the question becomes, under what circumstances would anyone claim that a person should not be self-actualized? One might also wonder what would be the consequences of living one's entire life in a state of self-actualization vs non self-actualization.
It is this sort of question that Rand addresses in the book. She makes the rather bold moral claim that each human should live a self-actualized life, and that to avoid doing so is to commit a moral failing.
Now let's quickly examine the concept from a political perspective. What would it mean to not be selfish?
Suppose you are a young man who is very talented at the Violin. You know in your gut that to create beautiful music with the instrument will bring you tremendous happiness and pride. You want nothing in life other than to experience this happiness every day, so you practice long and hard. That you please others is nice, but it's secondary to your own love of music.
Rand would applaud such a person. Rand's critics would claim that the violinist should have been "selfless" and joined the clergy or perhaps become an orderly at a hospital, helping to clean up vomit and spilled fluids.
By definition, selfishness is doing something you want to do, and selflessness is doing something you don't want to do. So what Rand's critics are advocating is akin to self-flagellation. This is not a new idea, as anyone who has read or watched the DaVinci Code knows -- the wacky priest uses a spiked strap to make sure that he is not enjoying whatever he is doing, since self-sacrifice is his highest value.
So what about people who work for non profits, are they selfless? Not really. They simply enjoy making the world better more than they enjoy earning more money in each paycheck. Selflessness for someone who works at a non profit would be working in a job that was truly meaningless... such as perhaps working as a clerk in a huge corporation.
Political systems like Socialism which attempt to embody the idea of shared self-sacrifice would view the clerical job as every bit as noble as a more meaningful job because someone must do the clerical work for it helps society as a whole.
Rand's value of individual choice and self-actualization -- appreciating and glorifying the occasions when a person truly loves his life's work -- is fortunately not all that foreign to HN readers.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThanks for this rebuttal. I did not have time to read the article. It's interesting that these same concepts are found in existentialism -- another philosophy that has been given a bad rap by many.
- mquander 17y agoThat's wonderful, if you can hack it. However, in the real world, we have billions of people on the planet who are not capable of living the life they imagine. What people take issue with is Rand's ideological claim that the best way for the people of Earth to achieve a future in which everyone has the capability to "self-actualize" is to focus primarily on their own "self-actualization." That's not obvious at all. Most people feel that our overall well-being is served when the most fortunate among us (those with the resources to pursue their own dreams, and excess resources beyond that) are taxed to some degree to try to give other people a better chance at a self-actualized life.
- grandalf 17y agoIf Rand is wrong and morality is to be found only in doing things one doesn't enjoy, doesn't that sort of take the wind out of the sails of anyone who might claim to enjoy something like working to help the homeless, etc? Do you view all of those people as noble souls who would quite rather be working on a trading floor somewhere but are gritting their teeth in self-suppression as they provide social services to others? Rand would argue that if someone derives meaning from solving a world problem such as homelessness, that his/her selfish (self-actualized) pursuit of that goal is the highest thing he/she can do. note: Rand's essay is not at all about taxation. The conceptual overlap comes from the tradition of the church to use the ethic of self-sacrifice to get members to do its bidding... a meme that has also been used by the state to justify unequal taxation regimes. I don't think the "ethic of self-sacrifice" argument is necessary to justify basic taxation -- simple social contract theory is enough -- but the meme works quite well b/c it allows the state to also be the arbiter of virtue.
- mquander 17y agoWell, I don't believe that morality has anything to do with whether you enjoy what you do. I don't think I completely understand how I perceive morality, though, so I wouldn't want to get in an argument about it. So perhaps we are on the same page. I don't think that the pursuit of self-sacrifice is inherently noble (or useful), but I don't think that the pursuit of self-actualization is inherently noble (or useful) either. I think that we should be enacting policies and laws encouraging people to act for the overall good of society, which often, but not always, will correlate with their own purely selfish aims. I think that it's possible to do that in a way that creates a better world than what we would find when everyone acts in their own interest alone.