3 ms·
Seems to me the problem pointed out only exists if you view the transactions without taking their larger context into account. Take his "100 Widget @ 1BTC each
by bigiain 13y ago
Seems to me the problem pointed out only exists if you view the transactions without taking their larger context into account.
Take his "100 Widget @ 1BTC each to produce, sell them later at a different value of BTC." scenario, which he characterises as an 80% loss. Now consider where the widget maker would have got his initial 100BTC from, and what he'll do with the BTC he sold the widgets for. Using his numbers, lets say you sold 50lb of butter to get your initial 100BTC. Several months later, when you've sold all your widgets (for the deflated 0.2BTC price) and you've got 20BTC in your wallet, you convert that back into your original resources, and get 100lbs of butter at the new 0.2/lb rate. All of a sudden the exact same scenario now looks like a 100% profit (50lb of butter becomes 100lb) instead of an 80% loss (100BTC becomes 20BTC). Admittedly, hanging on to the original 100BTC would have allowed the widget maker to sit on his hands for a few months and then buy 500lbs of butter, but looking at just the BTC deflation without the outside context makes things look very much worse than they really are. And ultimately, it's butter (or opamps or widgets) that you need to eat/live and that have "real value" in some sense - those 100BTC could just as easily have turned out to be worthless at the end of the widget production run - and the widgets could still have been sold for USD or traded for butter. The guy with a private key to a magic number proclaiming "100 BTC" might have had _nothing_ Not a problem if you can afford the gamble - not such a great idea if you _need_ that butter to feed yoru family.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoYou're missing the point entirely. It's about opportunity costs. If you try to use a deflationary currency for any economic activity then you get bitten by deflation, you end up losing money. The fact that the total revenue you get back is still worth the same (in butter or what-have-you) is irrelevant. You still had to buy equipment, you still had to pay people wages, and so forth in that currency to start with. But if you had not invested that money to start with you'd be even wealthier. The major point is that bitcoins or dollars aren't actually worth anything intrinsically. They have no value. Value exists in goods and services. With a deflationary currency people are discouraged from economic activity which produces more goods and services because it causes them to lose money.
- bigiain 13y agoI think I was making a _different_ point. I think BTC is a perfectly fine transactional tool. Much like credit cards. I can buy and sell things with my credit card, but I can't eat positive or negative numbers on my bank statement - in one sense it's not "real" until I turn those numbers into something of "value", perhaps butter - perhaps some other abstraction of "value" that I trust, like dollars. Dollars as an "asset" are reasonably safe. Using dollar assets for investment in other value-generating activity is fairly well understood. But ask anyone from Greece or Zimbabwe if they'd entrust their families future to their local fiat currency… BTC as an "investment" or "asset" are quite different. There's _very_ much more reason to hold on to BTC rather than invest them in any activity that's going to return less than several hundred percent annualised returns (there's a _very_ good reason why Silkroad's major commodities were what they were). If I can expect to double the dollar value of my bitcoin holding just by waiting another few weeks, of course I'm not going to invest any of that into widget raw materials or manufacturing plants. But there is definitely a US property market style risk for people sitting on large number of BTC. The notional "value" keeps going up at a startling rate - but it's still a crap shoot - there's nothing _guaranteeing_ you'll get any value at all out of your BTC - it's even less "sure" then US residential property market or Credit Default Swaps or Collateralized Debt Obligations from a few years back. It's not impossible you could buy "$25kUDS worth of BTC" today, and find you've got _nothing_ next year, instead of $50k or $100k or $500k - there were _lots_ of investors and property speculators with expectations like that 5 or 10 years ago≥
- InclinedPlane 13y agoGiven that bitcoin only has notional value: if it's not used as a currency, with prices denominated in it, then what supports its value? If nothing does then you have the recipe for a speculative bubble, and crash, and little else. At least gold can be made into pretty jewelry and electronics.
- bigiain 13y agoIt's pretty much the same as post-fund-raising stock market "value". Snapchat is "worth" 4 billion dollars in exactly the same way as a bitcoin is worth $1000 - enough people _believe_ it's "worth" that much that you can buy and sell some form of notional ownership of them - at least in small amounts – based on that value. If everybody stops believing in bitcoin or Snapchat, that value will plummet and perhaps disappear. The government will try to prevent that happening to USD, but ask a Greek or Zimbabwe person how their fiat currency has gone as a "reliable store of wealth". So long as people keep believing in BTC it _might_ maintain a real value - it does provide some real-world convenience to some people, so it's not impossible that it'll maintain long-tern value I guess. I can't help but think though, that there's way more people "talking it up" because they have enough BTC stashed that another order of magnitude increase in BTC conversion rates will have many of them jumping to exit with "fuck you" amounts of money - with the inevitable deflation as their BTC all hits the market in a big rush…