4 ms·
In other news, the 4th amendment doesn't cover internet communications because "there's no social consensus on an expectation of privacy" there. https://news.y
by SilasX 13y ago
In other news, the 4th amendment doesn't cover internet communications because "there's no social consensus on an expectation of privacy" there.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6803409 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6803409
- rayiner 13y agoGood job taking my post out of context. That post was in a sub thread about a broad general right to privacy. Not just narrow protections of electronic communications, but all sorts of tracking that doesn't qualify as a search or seizure. No such right exists. The Constitution doesn't even say the word privacy, nor did the framers write about it in the federalist papers or contemporaneous writings. My post was about what it would take for the Supreme Court to conjure such a broad right to privacy out of thin air. What it would take is a broad social consensus that such a right should exist. My point was that the tech community is undermining the establishment of that consensus by conditioning people to see online communications as a commercial transaction that can be data mined for advertising and tracking.
- SilasX 13y agoWhat specifically did I misrepresent? Can you fit it into this format: SilasX's post suggested this about rayiner's post: [ ] But, upon reading the full context of rayiner's post, that would be a misrepresentation because: [ ] As it stands, all I get out of your comment is, "Hey, you took my post out of context. [Reiterate the post]." Please tell me it's something more than "you made my argument seem bad".
- rayiner 13y agoYour post makes it seem like my post is about Internet communications. But that sub thread was about a general right to privacy, which is a broader concept. You can shoehorn some elements of Internet privacy into the existing 4th amendment framework. Straightforward analogies to wire taps will get you a long way. But there is a lot of surveillance that doesn't fit the mold of existing 4th amendment protections, particularly those based on tracking using third party or even public information. My post was about what it would take for the Supreme Court to find a general right of privacy that could encompass things that aren't obviously searches or seizures. Obviously finding a broad right of privacy would take an act of legislating from the bench much larger than simply extending existing wire tap protections to Skype calls. Your post implies that I think a broad social consensus is necessary for the latter.
- SilasX 13y ago>Your post makes it seem like my post is about Internet communications. So? It was, in part. If you're going to say someone is "misrepresenting" you simply on the basis that you talked about more than that one thing, then no one has every been correctly represented in the history of humanity. Please stop crying wolf, and apologize for your baseless accusation.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- potatolicious 13y agoRight. Our current guarantees of privacy are already well beyond what the Constitution explicitly sets out (which, strictly read, only covers persons and things). I think what rayiner is saying is that in order for SCOTUS to declare these internet communications protected, it either needs some extraordinary rationale, or more simply/easily the bulk of the populace needs to believe these communications are protected. If the typical person believes these communications are private, then this falls under the reasonable expectation of privacy legal test already accepted by SCOTUS.
- xerophtye 13y agoNo, i think what he is pointing at is that privacy is more than just "dont wire tap my calls", "dont read my private message". He says that privacy is much broader than that. I dont want websites tracking what i do. I dont want google saving my search history. Even though i (and many others) put some stuff public (or viewable to friends of friends etc), I dont want anyone using all my public information to stalk me and main a profile of me etc. The list can go on and on. His point is that the law shouldn't extend to things explicitly labelled as "private" or "password-protected". It extends to the use of my public info. And thus we need more work here to come to a consensus what is acceptable and what is not.
- danenania 13y agoIt's quite clear if you study historical jurisprudence and relevant case law that the authors of the constitution did not actually intend to create a limited government that respects freedom and human rights, but an elaborate linguistic puzzle for future lawyers and politicians to find loopholes in.