3 ms·
Can someone summarise why the FDA have any say in genetic testing? It's not as if they are selling a drug or other substance that might be incorrectly made or
by rwmj 13y ago
Can someone summarise why the FDA have any say in genetic testing? It's not as if they are selling a drug or other substance that might be incorrectly made or labelled. Presumably spitting into a vial can't cause harm.
- booyaa00 13y agoIf you're going to market something that can allegedly test and diagnose illnesses, it sure as hell should be tested and regulated. I hope 23andme is shutdown.
- mynewwork 13y agoI don't understand the anger and animosity at 23andme I've seen on HN lately. Maybe I'm not understanding something the way you are. My understanding is they sequence some of your dna, and then link to various publicly available studies to show users "This paper showed this mutation correlates with this disease". Is that not a correct description of their service? Why do you want them shut down?
- booyaa00 13y agoThe problem is, most people aren't trained doctors. They will have no idea how to interpret the results. They will likely go waste their own doctors time worrying about everything. 23andme is preying on some peoples fears, and turning them into hypercondriacs. The absolute vast majority of people will die from heart disease or cancer. What is the point of paying money to find that out? Obviously there's also the privacy aspect as well - trusting your DNA to some private company who wants to make profit. If you have a symptom, or family history of some disease, go see a doctor. That's kinda what they're there for. And they train for years in order that they can interpret results correctly.
- route66 13y agoYes, of course. The article does that. [23andMe] ... edged closer and closer to marketing their services as a way of predicting and even preventing health problems. And any kit intended to cure, mitigate, treat, prevent, or diagnose a disease is, according to federal law, a "medical device" that needs to be deemed safe and effective by the FDA.
- breischl 13y agoWhile I have no particular knowledge of the case, the FDA checks that services are safe and effective. Basically that the company isn't selling proverbial snake oil (or literal snake oil, I guess). Providing incorrect or misleading information could lead to people making health decisions with potentially serious consequences. If that information is wrong people could take unnecessary risks with their health.
- joosters 13y ago"FDA is concerned about the public health consequences of inaccurate results from the PGS device - the main purpose of compliance with FDA's regulatory requirements is to ensure that the tests work," said Alberto Gutierrez, director of the FDA's centre for devices and radiological health, in a letter to the company. "Patients relying on such tests may begin to self-manage their treatment through dose changes or even abandon certain therapies depending on the outcome of the assessment," he added. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-25100878 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-25100878