9 ms·
I think Bitcoin's doomed to fail, but not for the reasons the article suggest. There're ample historical counterexamples of currencies that are not tied to a g
by nostrademons 13y ago
I think Bitcoin's doomed to fail, but not for the reasons the article suggest.
There're ample historical counterexamples of currencies that are not tied to a government. Gold is the most obvious example; if currency was inextricably tied to governments, there would not have been a mad rush to colonize the New World (and extract its gold reserves). In prisons cigarettes frequently serve as currency, as a medium of exchange that is widely valued.
What really makes a currency is confidence. People have to believe that other people will continue to value the currency later. Government backing can provide one source of confidence. But so can strong crypto, and one could argue that these days people have more confidence in crypto than in governments.
What'll really kill Bitcoin is that this speculative wave has made the price incredibly volatile, so volatile that real merchants selling real goods have no idea what to price things at. So everyone holding Bitcoins purchases them for investment value, and then the price will crash when it stops going up. That destroys confidence in the currency, which destroys the currency.
I could easily see a successor currency based on the Bitcoin protocol emerging from the ashes, though. By then the speculators will have been burned so badly that they'll stay far away, so it'll quietly gain adoption in the background, and then eventually become the new currency of choice when inflation starts to make it's way through current fiat currencies.
- TylerE 13y agoAlso, with gold, there is intrinsic value beyond the monetary - jewelry use, or in these moderns days in electronics. That provides a value floor. Bitcoin doesn't have that.
- kdeforche 13y agoFor bitcoin it's easy to argue that it's useful for almost zero-cost transactions, world wide, with relatively short confirmation times. Other applications are being invented: cryptographic proof-of-existence (on top of the block chain) or perhaps also distributed/anonymous DNS. You really need to see it as a powerful idea, not just a speculative asset
- dmix 13y agoEvery bitcoin thread = groundhog day.
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoSeriously, in these threads there's hardly any middle ground between, "eventually these young fools will see they are standing at the foot of a pyramid of tulips," and, "fuck the police fuck fiat currency eventually dollars will be obsolete." Both sides are ignorant IMO.
- kordless 13y agoNope. Gold is used in limited quantities for plating pins in electronics, covering space helmets, and probably a few other things. It's really not that valuable for getting shit done and need a lot of it type of stuff.
- patmcc 13y agoThe use of gold in industry is discouraged by its high price - if it were the same price as copper, you'd see more uses for it.
- TylerE 13y agoIf by limited quantities you mean "about 400 tons a year" (and that's not counting dentistry or jewelry) then yes. 11,666,666 troy ounces $15,108,332,470 at today's prices. If you do count jewelry, increase those figured by approx. an order of magnitude.
- jamestnz 13y agoSomething that might be considered an "intrinsic" value of bitcoin is its ability to instantly and securely transfer wealth across large distances at zero or near-zero cost. This is an feature not present in some of the incumbent currencies and store-of-value assets. For example, physically shipping hundreds of kilograms of gold (or physical, folding USD) is a costly exercise fraught with security risks, and the risk profile varies depending on many factors, for instance the political situations in the sending and receiving countries. Transferring large amounts of electronic USD across international borders via the traditional banking system is going to invoke all kinds of reporting requirements, and possibly higher transaction costs (though you can do large wire transfers for like $25 I think). Transferring arbitrary amounts via bitcoin is easy, secure and the transaction itself is cost-effective (notwithstanding the current relative difficulty/expense of moving large amounts of fiat currency into and out of bitcoin in the first place, which problem I'd expect to ease as the btc economy matures).
- TylerE 13y agoI think you misunderstand me. I am talk about non-currency use. If the Bitcoin network collapses, you have nothing. The market for gold by definition cannot collapse to zero as it has non-currency industrial and decorative value.
- kdeforche 13y agoIf the electricity collapses, the light goes out. Stay away from LEDs.
- fat0wl 13y agoThis intrinsic value can be mirrored by any cryptocurrency or even just a parallel network of Bitcoin. It is no justification for $1000/coin the way overzealous BTC investors claim.
- VMG 13y agoNetwork Effect
- 13y ago
- hacknat 13y agoThis assumes that stability comes from a lack of speculation. This is not true. A majority of any modern currency's stability comes from its government's ability to ease and tighten the money supply as they see fit.
- asperous 13y agoPersonally, I don't believe in Bitcoin either, but one thing I was considering is that Bitcoin is usable as long as its value isn't 0 (though it might be incredibly difficult to use with fluctuations). So the question is will it crash to 0? Seeing the price soar to 1,000 means that people in the future might always be willing to purchase it at some price, hoping that it will return to that level. Though, as it stands I don't think speculation gives it credibility. People who believe that are creating the positive reinforcement cycle so common in economic bubbles.
- fat0wl 13y agothis is the root of my belief as well -- that it is a speculative farce, but so long as it is above 0 it will continue to be in use. Another poster made me aware of this joke that I think summarizes Bitcoin pretty accurately. http://www.getamused.com/jokes/pennystock.html http://www.getamused.com/jokes/pennystock.html Only in this case it's not a single buyer.
- vectorpush 13y agoOnly in this case it's not a single buyer. i.e. completely invalidating the comparison.
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoThat's not true, there could be multiple buyers and the punchline would just be, "to whom? there's only the three of you."
- vectorpush 13y agoThat punchline would make no sense. The client would reply "to the market of two buyers".
- reginaldjcooper 13y agothat's right, I had a momentary lapse in judgement, sorry
- johnrob 13y agoIt's possible that bitcoin simply functions as a casino (or "volatile asset") instead of a medium of exchange, given the large demand for gambling.
- Aqueous 13y agoIf you use a service like BitPay, which most BitCoin merchants too, you declare your price in dollars and the API uses the current exchange rate to convert it to BitCoin, minute-by-minute. The prices float up and down with the currency, so pricing is largely a non-problem. It makes rational sense for merchants to accept BitCoin and to keep some holdings in BitCoin because the price is increasing at such a rapid pace. Why wouldn't you want to sell something for x BTC today when that amount could be worth twice as much tomorrow? For the same reason it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to spend a BitCoin. Eventually the currency will level out when the incentive to spend equalizes with the incentive to receive. This might not happen for a while as long as speculation remains the predominant driving force.
- patmcc 13y ago>>It makes rational sense for merchants to accept BitCoin and to keep some holdings in BitCoin because the price is increasing at such a rapid pace. Why wouldn't you want to sell something for x BTC today when that amount could be worth twice as much tomorrow? By this logic you should put all your available cash into bitcoins right now. Are you? If not, why not?
- Aqueous 13y agoI don't put all of my money into BitCoin right now for the same reason I don't put it into any other promising investment. The simple answer is that I don't know everything and something could come out of left field tomorrow and demolish BitCoin's value. A bug in the software, more overbearing government regulation, some government in the world (not the US, I don't think) banning BitCoin, etc.... I'm betting that this won't happen which is why I have as much as I do in BitCoin right now.
- trekky1700 13y agoIf you're valuing everything in dollars, setting your price in dollars, and converting to and from dollars, why not just use dollars. I think this is the leap BitCoin is yet to make. When we no longer have to convert it and compare it to dollars. It has loads of benefits over using the dollar, but a lot of those benefits are lost the second you're having it exchanged. For instance, if I wanted to use bitcoin for contracting, my clients would have to convert their dollars into bitcoins, then I'd accept the bitcoins smoothly and easily, and then I'd have to exchange them (sell them) back for dollars to buy groceries and pay for the bus. Whereas right now, I get an Interac e-transfer and in less than 30 seconds I have money I can go to the store with, and it cost the sender only a dollar in fees. Sure, it's taxable, but the second I convert it from bit coins it's trackable anyway. I definitely think this is a model we're going to see a lot more of in the future, but Bitcoin with it's thousand dollar and rising valuation and constant fluctuations is very difficult to get behind and actively use. And with the number of people, just of the people I know, who bought in hoping to cash out, there might be quite the tumble on the way. Who knows though, it will be interesting to watch, that's for sure.
- novalis78 13y agoHave you seen the interview with Bobby Lee recently? I think he made a great point. They asked him if he is worried that the bitcoin fluctuations undermine bitcoins' ability to function as a currency and discourages merchant adoption rate. He said that's what he initially thought as well, but since has come to the conclusion that bitcoin has to be seen foremost as a store of value and only through the "confidence" as you put it in a long term storage of value will the adoption as a currency eventually come all by itself. So he is not worried at all. Found the link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zz_yfB72S9c http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zz_yfB72S9c
- andyidsinga 13y agoI love your point about pricing - was just thinking the other day about how I might accept bitcoin for an item. Presumably there could be a mechanism for determining the right price on the fly (similar to share pricing) but volatility would still be killer - hence there would be desire for a bartered item or non-volatile currency.
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoI have been thinking about this also and I concluded I would either account for the bitcoin volatility risk in my BTC price or by raising the dollar price.
- dreamdu5t 13y agoInteresting that the speculative wave responsible for the growth of bitcoin is blamed for what is preventing it from growing. Not very convincing. If anything, the speculative phase matches the growth process bitcoin enthusiasts have predicted.
- varjag 13y ago> Government backing can provide one source of confidence. But so can strong crypto, and one could argue that these days people have more confidence in crypto than in governments. Not quite. The confidence in "normal" fiat currency arises not so much from government backing, but from the fact that a well-managed national currency envelopes the GDP of a national economy. Government really needs fiscal discipline to not break the system (the consequences are well known); the trust part comes from the health of national economy and intersection of interests of all involved players. Consider a major issuer like USA or Eurozone. The strength of their currencies stems from strength of the backing economies. In theory, the government could try fooling the system and run the printing press amok. In practice, such a government would be very short-lived, as it would piss off just about every person with money. Save for outliers like Zimbabwe, there aren't really many cases of modern governments running themselves in the ground like that. Usually, runaway inflation is a consequence of a catastrophic event in the economy (bubbles, wars, loss of markets and other externalities). Now, a super-fiat currency like Bitcoin is not backed by anything like that. It is a virtual construct with finite supply, and crypto is just a production vehicle here. It envelopes no economy, so the all trust here comes from compound interest of people who invest into it.
- DrJokepu 13y agoIn addition, there are various measures a government or a central bank can take to stop or at least slow down escalating inflation. If there was a sudden loss of confidence in BitCoin (or more realistically, people lost confidence in other people’s confidence in BitCoin), such hyperinflation would spread and escalate with the speed of light with nothing to stop it. This kind of volatility might be interesting for speculative investment purposes but not incredibly useful as currency. Then again, it’s entirely possible that we will be proven wrong.
- alttab 13y agoThe bitcoin price won't stabilize until it's operation literally dictates demand. Once for all practical purposes everyday life is handled in satoshis, how does an economy expand?
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoYour examples have intrinsic value. This is pretty easy ...
- tlrobinson 13y agoI agree with everything you said, but why couldn't/wouldn't the currency emerging from the ashes be Bitcoin itself?
- betterunix 13y ago"There're ample historical counterexamples of currencies that are not tied to a government. Gold is the most obvious example" ...governments were accepting gold for tax purposes, kings were filling their treasuries with gold, armies were sent to steal gold from other countries, etc. Gold was absolutely tied to government when it was used as currency, and I am using the past tense here because gold is not a currency outside of a few highly niche markets. "What really makes a currency is confidence" I think you are confusing confidence with demand. What makes currencies work is demand -- the fact that everyone in the market demands the currency. Typically this happens because of a government, or more precisely because of a government that enforces certain laws. "so can strong crypto" Oh yeah? Let's just assume that Bitcoin actually qualified as "strong crypto." I'll release my fork of Bitcoin that is identical in every way, but happens to have its own block chain that I started using this post. How successful do you think that will be as a currency? Why can't we all just create our own personal block chains (and thus all be rich)? There is more to the story than "strong crypto."
- eru 13y agoNetwork effects.
- XorNot 13y agoThere was a mad rush to acquire gold from the new world, which promptly collapsed the economy of Spain. In practice, no one suddenly got richer because they'd gotten all this new gold, they just experienced massive inflation (and forgot to peg their tax rate to it, so their revenues collapsed but their expenditures did not and they went bankrupt). Because it turns out you can't eat gold nor make weapons or ships with it.
- 21echoes 13y ago> Gold is the most obvious example; if currency was inextricably tied to governments, there would not have been a mad rush to colonize the New World (and extract its gold reserves). wut. you do know what middle-ages, gov't issued currency was made of, don't you? and who funded the new world expeditions? and for what reason? and you do know that even given the spanish crown's desire to repay their debtors, the bulk of that gold and silver windfall ended up going to china to fund their switch away from paper money by the Ming dynasty? acting like gold != governments is... well, frankly, it's ignorant.
- erikb 13y agoWhat you describe is the failing of bitcoin itself. What the author discusses is the failing of all electronic, not-gov-backed currencies. I think as with every new thing we can be sure that bitcoin will go through a lot of trouble and the string b-i-t-c-o-i-n might be unusable in a short future. But pure electronic currencies will still strive when happen what you explain. What the author discusses are problems that will make all electronic currencies fail. So both topics can be discussed, but they are not really the same thread. And you might actually both be correct.