4 ms·
Ideological response: Police are the thugs that rich people buy to defend themselves from the poor. Actually, basic income / negative income tax is a very good
by barrkel 13y ago
Ideological response: Police are the thugs that rich people buy to defend themselves from the poor.
Actually, basic income / negative income tax is a very good idea, much better than welfare schemes of almost all kinds - it has almost no administration overhead. Charity, like you advocate, has huge amounts of overhead. Milton Friedman was an advocate, for example, and he was hardly a socialist.
And the idea that charity comes from goodness? That is utter bullshit. It's 95% social signalling. Altruism doesn't exist.
- ctdonath 13y agoPolice are assigned to serve all, protecting poor as well. If welfare is going to be provided to such a large scale as we do, then yes I'd rather the BI approach just to keep things simple and efficient - and to reveal the veiled problems a complex welfare system conceals. And no, charity is not utter bullshit. What I do isn't signaling anything to anyone, as I keep it as low-profile & anonymous as possible. Altruism exists, and the nature of it means you don't know much about that of others precisely because its nature is to be low-profile & anonymous.
- evacuationdrill 13y agoCome to Houston, where most of the departments operating here earn lots of income from neighborhoods. Your HOA pays the departments to guarantee periodic patrols or even guarantee an officer present somewhere inside 24/7. This is not the same as off-duty police being hired; they pay the department toward officer salaries. Just because they're sworn to protect doesn't mean they can't prefer to protect certain areas.
- rjohnk 13y agoExhibit A negating your last statement: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6805699 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6805699
- jl6 13y agoI've seen a lot of genuine charity motivated by religion, but we seem to have thrown the baby out with the bathwater on that one.
- judk 13y agoOn behalf of the anonymous good people of the world: you are wrong.