2 ms·
The spread of pop culture is one of the reasons that many anti-American zealots latch onto as justification. So yes, Schwarzenegger, Michael Jackson, McDonald'
by bilbo0s 19y ago
The spread of pop culture is one of the reasons that many anti-American zealots latch onto as justification. So yes, Schwarzenegger, Michael Jackson, McDonald's and Starbucks, they all have a great deal to do with the perceived American cultural hegemony. As Jet Li, Jackie Chan and, foolish as it may seem, Chinese restaurants, all have a great deal to do with Chinese cultural hegemony.
The question that confuses me is this. Why worry ONLY about American cultural hegemony, when CLEARLY the Chinese cultural hegemony is also an issue? Why worry ONLY about American cultural hegemony, when Japanese cultural hegemony is also an issue?
I maintain that there is something subtle here that we are somehow missing. There HAS to be. Why do the French blow up McDonald's and not the restaurants in the Chinese section of Paris over by Le Marais? There are as many instructors of Chinese martial arts in Munich as there are hip hop clubs. Why single us out? There are MORE girls playing with Tomagotchis than there are listening to Hannah Montana. Why does she need so much more security?
Everything you wrote in your post as touching China is (somewhat) factual. Yet most non-Americans consider the United States and Iran to be the prime threats to global peace. Why?
In short, what I am saying is that none of this makes sense to me. That this situation is very disconcerting.
If there are non-Americans reading this thread, I would REALLY like your opinion on these matters.
- corentin 19y agoFirst, let's get this clear: as far as I know, we only have two cases of McDonald's restaurants attacks in France. One non-violent, symbolic dismantlement by leftist leader Jose Bove and one bomb attack by right-wing independendists in Brittany (it killed one person). As far as I'm concerned, I mostly listen to US music, read US authors and watch US movies so basically I can't speak against your culture (well, OUR culture that is). It's so much rich and broad than what we have here. And most french people (secretly) agree; but they're way too proud to admit it. What europeans and basically the rest of the world really hate is your leaders. Not that ours are better, but at least they don't use massive fire power against other countries (I'm talking about western europe here; Russian leaders are certainly as crazy as the hawks in Washington). Oh, by the way: french people don't really like China in fact; they blame it for "stealing" our jobs.
- bilbo0s 19y agoJust to dig a little deeper I wanted to ask a few questions. I assume you are Franco-American. Is this true? Secondly, I am certain that you are aware that your own leaders are rattling the sabers for war with Iran right now as well. Why is it that the French would elect Sarko, and continue to bash Bush? (I am no friend of Bush by the way, it's just something I have been wondering). Next, you say that you love our culture, and from what I see in Paris I would have to agree. You also seem a little sino-phillic as well, with martial arts, Chinese medicine, and the Chinese film industry doing as well as it is in France. Would it be fair to say then that CULTURAL hegemony, either American or Chinese, is not what is so galling to the rest of the world. Rather the, military hegemony in the case of the US, and the financial hegemony, in the case of Japan and China? Do you believe it is the military and financial hegemonies that spook others? Lastly, the wording of my post was probably poor. When I said that the French blow up McDonald's restaurants, I was referring to the incident in Brittany. I only mentioned Paris because I wanted to point out a well known place, in a well known city where another cultural hegemony had a foothold.
- davidw 19y agoI can't quite pin down what it is, but I think this is the most reddit-like thread I've read here in a while. Perhaps it's words like 'hegemony', mentioning of Bush, war, and so on.
- corentin 19y agoWhat's wrong with reddit-like, as long as it's not trolling, ad-hominem, three-word messages and stuff?
- davidw 19y agoWell, the original article was pretty far off-topic, and that has only bred discussions that are even further ranging. I guess I find bilbo0s' postings to be a bit vague and not well defined. China has a hegemony because it has a few actors and lots of restaurants? Can Italy be one too, then? That brought out the comparison by ph0rque, typical of reddit posts, that the US is "just like (X|Y|Z)". And now I'm adding meaningless meta-commentary. Bleagh:-( (BTW, your comments were brief and to the point, and weren't what I was taking issue with).
- Caligula 19y agoI think it has to do with the dominance of american culture that is changing every aspect of their lives. You mentioned Jet Li, Jackie Chan. They are more known internationally for their American movies than anything they made in HK. Also Chinese food is American. The food you would have at an American Chinese restaurant has little in common with what you would experience in China. The same American Chinese food was exported to France. So its more American than anything else. The martial arts instructors you mention exist largely because of Hollywood. The reason people dislike America is because its the wealthiest, most powerful nation on earth that can do whatever it wants regardless of what other nations think, and it does.
- bilbo0s 19y agoI think that is part of it, but Hollywood does not explain all of it. Chow Yun-Fat was big in Europe long before 'Anna and the King'. When we put him into video games, we put him in the roles that he played in his HK films, the roles that he played in his american films were far less memorable. Zhang Ziyi is an amazing actress and the world knows this because of 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon', though 'Rush Hour 2' was really good, as you said. And women the world over LOVE the film '2046'. I take that DVD with me where ever I go, in case I get a date. It is ALWAYS a winner. With a name like 'caligula' you should make sure this movie is in your collection too. Having been obliged to eat at crappy Chinese restaurants from China Town in Havana, Cuba to Hong Kong, I have to say that it all tastes the same to me. That said, I am sure if I set my sites on the higher end restaurants I would probably find the difference in the 'experience' that you spoke about. I think maybe you might be right about Hollywood pushing martial arts though. This still leaves open the question of the worldwide fixation with things like Chinese medicines for example.