2 ms·
If every child is eligible for his fair share of minimum income, there's a good incentive to direct productive-work energy into baby-making activities, boosting
by prostoalex 13y ago
If every child is eligible for his fair share of minimum income, there's a good incentive to direct productive-work energy into baby-making activities, boosting household's basic income numbers with each new addition.
- iSnow 13y agoWith the aging population in Japan and Europe this sounds not so bad.
- mildtrepidation 13y agoWhich is great if you don't consider overpopulation a problem. It's good to try and ensure a high standard of living and economic comfort, but that doesn't happen in a vacuum: If your solution encourages procreation, it's important to review that not just in terms of problems it might solve but also those it might create or exacerbate (as well as results that may not be so clearly positive or negative but will introduce further change).
- judk 13y agoIndeed. I haven't see mincome in (usually religious) cultures that promote massive reproduction (6+ children surviving to adulthood). In the long run, birh control must be a key component of mincome. This aspect makes people squeamish, sadly for the wrong reasons.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> If every child is eligible for his fair share of minimum income, there's a good incentive to direct productive-work energy into baby-making activities, boosting household's basic income numbers with each new addition. That kind of assumes basic income adds to rather than replaces existing welfare programs, which already have this feature. If it replaces them -- as most basic income advocates propose -- there is no reason to expect much change in this dimension, except that people already on the programs would, under basic income, have low-wage jobs as an option -- in place of baby-making -- to get more money, where in the status quo with means-tested programs, a low-wage job is often a net loss even in the immediate term, because it reduces benefits (sometimes 1:1, sometimes even greater by passing a sharp cutoff for important benefits.)
- prostoalex 13y agoBut the argument for replacement rests on reduced administrative costs of the replaced programs. If you still have to employ bureaucracy to monitor eligibility and combat fraud, you're kinda back to square one.