4 ms·
Well, these tools are essential to many hackers, so the posts are definitely relevant to HN. IMO, it makes much more sense to view all such news in a central lo
by w1ntermute 17y ago
Well, these tools are essential to many hackers, so the posts are definitely relevant to HN. IMO, it makes much more sense to view all such news in a central location (i.e., HN), rather than subscribing to individual projects' RSS feeds, where one would also be notified of developmental releases.
- tsally 17y agoI can count over 100 tools essential to many hackers. The *nix userland alone is certainly several hundred. How about the release notes for all the languages we use? Or perhapes the editors and IDEs? Also, if you want one central location, I suggest an RSS reader. And if you're worried about volume, many readers have filter functionality as well.
- socratees 17y agoYeah, but the HN community follows the development of browsers, internet software etc., with special attention. So it is essential that we discuss our thoughts about the software that matters to us most.
- shpxnvz 17y agoWouldn't it make more sense then to have a post about a specific new feature/change/bug of the software in question, rather than a general announcement?
- w1ntermute 17y agoThe general announcement provides a page on which we can start threaded discussions on specific features, which can be quite useful, especially since many of the features significantly impact one another.
- randallsquared 17y agoThat would make tsally's problem worse, since every significant new feature would have a spot on HN, rather than having all related features grouped under a few spots.
- w1ntermute 17y agoI can count over 100 tools essential to many hackers. So can I, but few come to my mind as swiftly as Firefox. It (with the aid of Firebug) is an invaluable tool for hacking on web sites. I know several people (including myself) who use it for that very purpose even if they do not use it as their primary browser. Firefox definitely stands out among the crowd of myriad hacker tools.
- olefoo 17y agoShouldn't your central location be your rss reader? Most of the projects you mention have low-traffic announce feeds that only post on release. You are basically demanding that a scarce public resource (HN front page) be used up to satisfy a need you could take care of on your own. It's kind of humbling to see the tragedy of the commons playing out so clearly here.
- yangyang 17y agoPerhaps I'm unusual, but I find the dicussion is often as interesting as the link (perhaps not for this item :-). And you don't get that on an announcements RSS feed.
- w1ntermute 17y agoIt is not just "my" need that is being satisfied. Clearly, at least 73 (the current number of votes) other hackers find this information (and like yangyang said, a place to converse about it) useful. The "scarce public resource" is being used in the way that would satisfy the needs of the largest number of hackers. That said, you needn't worry about HN being polluted with release notes. It just so happened that several major pieces of software had releases today. This is most definitely not a daily occurrence.