3 ms·
The problem isn't that Google integrated Youtube's comments into a unified social layer. Integrating Youtube comments, Blogger comments, Picasaweb comments, a
by Pxtl 13y ago
The problem isn't that Google integrated Youtube's comments into a unified social layer. Integrating Youtube comments, Blogger comments, Picasaweb comments, a Facebook-like social network into a single system?
That's a great idea.
The problem is that they screwed the pooch on it in every way I can imagine. They soft-pedaled the rollout which made it into a million tiny pain-points and broken promises instead of one big one.
They completely screwed up their automoderation algorithm. It's a failure. Whatever Youtube used before is obviously better.
They made the system far too opinionated, not giving the page owner any moderation tools or filters or anything - the page owners can't allow/deny pseudonymous accounts (and even the existence of pseudonymous accounts is unclear).
They didn't offer any anonymous approach, and the pseudonymous system is bizarre and unclear.
If you're building a single social tool like Facebook, being opinionated helps. But if you're building a whole social platform that you're bolting onto every form of content your users run? Every video, every blogpost, every picture? You need to let the users have the tools to run their comment-sections.
- rocky1138 13y agoI agree with everything you've just written. On an unrelated note, I read "comment-section" as "commentcision" and thought you'd coined up a new phrase to describe how users want their online persona handled.
- est 13y ago> That's a great idea. It's a failed idea. Aggregation protocols (RSS and ATOM) abandoned, Friendfeed died. Because gulping from every source possible without digestion (!) means diarrhea Are there any good digestion algorithms or content filtering service out there? No. For every new merged info, the only thing increased is noise, not signal. In separated channels, like Picasa, Blogger, Youtube, you can prioritize them, you can reply blogger comments while ignore youtube trolls, but in a merged timeline, you will have serious management troubles
- Pxtl 13y ago> It's a failed idea. Aggregation protocols (RSS and ATOM) abandoned, Friendfeed died. Because gulping from every source possible without digestion (!) means diarrhea RSS failed because it wasn't user-friendly enough for non-geeks. Other tools that let users drink from a firehose of unrelated info like Reddit and Twitter do just fine. Diarrhea or not, they get users.