10 ms·
I'm still trying to wrap my head around the idea that there's a world out there where you can just casually hit up Grammaw and Uncle Barry for twenty grand apie
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
I'm still trying to wrap my head around the idea that there's a world out there where you can just casually hit up Grammaw and Uncle Barry for twenty grand apiece.
It doesn't really favor the notion that the startup world is an egalitarian meritocracy.
- beat 13y agoI should add that I've been "Uncle Barry" too. One of my poor sisters and her daughter tried to get me to loan them ten grand to help start a business, and I refused. Why? Because their plan was nonsense. I think they have a good $20-30k/year idea, which is great, but they were absolutely convinced that it's a $100k business - something I consider impossible upon running various numbers and the limitations of hands-on work. If they're not willing to be realistic about their scope, I'm not going to hand them money to pour down a hole.
- dsugarman 13y agoIt is obviously not an egalitarian meritocracy, but there are serious opportunities for anyone with access to the internet. The less fortunate will face a lot more adversity to find success, which makes it that much sweeter.
- rayiner 13y ago"Egalitarian meritocracy" is relative. It used to be that going to Harvard was largely a measure of whether you had enough money to go to Harvard. In 1950, the acceptance rate at Harvard from elite preparatory schools was almost 90%. Today, it's an "egalitarian meritocracy." The acceptance rate is around 5-6%. A quarter of students come from families that make below $80k, and 60% of students receive some financial aid. In other words, a household income of $80k, which is top 30% nationwide, puts you at the bottom 25% mark at Harvard. Further, 40% of students apparently come from households making over $180k (the point at which aid phases out), which puts them in the top 5% or so of households nationwide. The statistics at Princeton, Stanford, etc, aren't any different. People in the start-up world talk about "egalitarian meritocracy" in the same breath as they say they give explicit preference to kids coming out of Stanford, a place where the median person is from the upper middle class. It's true in a purely relative sense. It's very meritocratic compared to how things were historically, and how things still are in many parts of the world. That is not to say that these institutions could be appreciably more meritocratic by their own efforts. Rather, when talking about whether a field is "meritocratic" you can't ignore the fact that class and income-based sorting takes place at a much earlier stage in the pipeline.
- natrius 13y agoIf merit correlates with the ability to make money and merit is heritable, you'd expect those with merit to come from families with money. Top schools and our industry are probably far from pure meritocracies, but that data doesn't prove (or even strongly suggest) it.
- amirmc 13y ago> "If merit correlates with the ability to make money and merit is heritable..." In the UK this was called being of 'good breeding'. It's no more true now than it was back then. Bear in mind that money is also heritable.
- natrius 13y agoYour claim that it isn't true is nice and all, but actual evidence that it isn't true would be better.
- Brakenshire 13y agoJust to clarify, you're asking him to prove that the rich aren't genetically superior to the poor?
- natrius 13y agoTo quote myself: "If merit correlates with the ability to make money and merit is heritable, you'd expect those with merit to come from families with money." Is my logic incorrect? Does merit not correlate with the ability to make money? Is merit not heritable? None of those questions have been answered, but we did get to see some good ad hominem reasoning.
- shubb 13y agoYou'd have to define merit. For instance, on the one hand 'general intelligence' has been shown to be heritable (via adopted twin studies), but on the other, 'general intelligence' scores have increased massively in Africa as schooling becomes more widespread. So, is general intelligence heritable? Do our tests for intelligence really measure how much like a middle class European you are? These are interesting academic questions, but I wonder if you'd agree with this - having access to 5MM in no questions asked family funding is more useful than 50 extra IQ points, because you can always hire clever people.
- foobarqux 13y agoBezos's parents invested 300k into Amazon or whatever it was called at first.
- beat 13y agoIt depends on the family. Hell, I drop a couple thou a year helping my retired mother financially, as she has zero money and zero sense with whatever little money she gets. My family has always been dirt poor (and those who are still dirt poor look enviously and somewhat resentfully on me and my one sister who also achieved a comfortable middle class life). My wife's family, on the other hand, is solidly upper middle class all around. Her grandfather worked from a Kansas dust bowl Depression childhood to a Harvard MBA and probably several million in net worth. Several of them are "qualified investors" in the legal sense and could angel-fund a startup. But I won't ask them for a cent, not even take it if it was offered. Why? Because they're family, and not blood family at that. If I took investment money from them and it failed, I would be paying for it in non-financial ways for the rest of my life, and my wife would be paying even worse. Even asking would be a tremendous misstep of the delicate dance of family. So yeah, even if Grammaw and Uncle Barry have twenty grand to invest doesn't mean there's anything "casual" about it.
- phamilton 13y ago20 grand isn't that much. Go hang out on mrmoneymustache.com or earlyretirementextreme.com and you'll see plenty of people with twenty grand set aside for "risky investments". It's especially true right now, as depression era children have all retired after a lifetime of deeply-ingrained frugal living.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoSee, this is kind of what I'm talking about. There's a world out there in which people can say "20 grand isn't that much" with a straight face. I guess it's nice that that world exists, but it really doesn't represent the experiences of most Americans.
- phamilton 13y agoI should rephrase. 20 grand isn't much over the course of a few decades. It's a lot for a 20 something year old fresh out of school. For someone in their 40s, having 20 grand available for such an investment isn't always the result of good fortune. It's a low enough sum that can be attributed merely to frugal living and smart financial decisions. It's easily the difference between packing a lunch instead of eating out every day throughout a career. It's the long term difference between driving used Hondas instead of new Hondas. I understand there are plenty of people who don't have such choices, but I guarantee there are plenty of individuals here on HN that could squirrel away 20k a year if they really tried. Saving 20k over the next decade is well within the reach of most individuals.
- clarky07 13y agoThis is exactly right. The parent is right that it doesn't represent the world of many Americans, but for most of them, it is their own fault. i'm sorry if that that offends anyone, but stop living beyond your means and you can save up 20k. It doesn't really matter how much you make. The key is to simply spend less than that number. FWIW, 20k is still a big number to me, but not that big and I'm a 20 something that quit my job a few years ago to start my own business. I didn't ask any family or friends for money, instead I saved for 2 years to give myself a > 12 month emergency fund / runway[1]. I can't imagine how people would ask for a loan/gift from family rather than simply live frugally for a year or two. [1] - my wife and i paid off ~30k in student loans, and saved a ~30k emergency fund in about 22 months making ~80k combined a year. We lived frugally so that I could quit my job and start my own business.
- Crito 13y agoSome families have little money, but are willing to lend what little they have among each other. Some families have plenty of money and are willing to lend to each other. Some families have plenty of money, and think that it is poor form to lend to family. People in my extended family go out of their way to help family members when they are down; for instance covering a few college loan payments or providing a bed to sleep on for a few weeks, but going to them for a business loan? That is not done, even with comparably small amounts of money. I kind of always assumed that was the common attitude, but I guess not.