3 ms·
"but we're not smart enough to receive information on the genes in our bodies." No, and that's not what he claimed. Society at-large is not sufficiently educat
by FireBeyond 13y ago
"but we're not smart enough to receive information on the genes in our bodies."
No, and that's not what he claimed. Society at-large is not sufficiently educated or informed enough to know whether 23andMe's genetic profiling regimen follows best practices, actually correctly interprets the genome, and provides information that is both open, accurate, and appropriately disclaimed, as needed.
23andMe has chosen to pay lip service to the FDA, and steadfastly refuse to respond. They know what is required, say "yes, yes, we'll do that", and then don't.
"The fact that they're not marketed as a clinical tool for diagnoses?"
Only by very careful wording, and even then only subjectively so - sufficiently so that the FDA is concerned.
"Arm your doctor with information on how you might respond to certain medications."
"A simple DNA test led to an unexpected diagnosis for a mother and daughter, changing their lives forever."
"Find out things like if your body metabolizes caffeine quickly, or if you're at a higher risk for diabetes."
Statements like these may not /literally/ be "clinical tools for diagnosis", but the reasonable layperson can easily interpret them as such. For comparison, I'm an EMS provider. We are taught all through school that we don't diagnose. We "assess" and "rule out" and "treat for", and only a physician diagnoses. Do you think we don't say "this person has appendicitis/other given condition", and act that way, and do you think it makes a great deal of difference to the patient I speak to? "I'm not diagnosing you with appendicitis or a kidney stone or a XXX, but that's what's going on."
- crusso 13y agopay lip service to the FDA, and steadfastly refuse to respond Seems to me that they've been going back and forth with the FDA for some time. My interpretation is that the FDA wants a strict legal interpretation that the AMA would be happy with. Probably the AMA would only be happy if doctors could get a cut of every genetic "test" being performed by 23AM. Only by very careful wording, and even then only subjectively so Subjectively, any interpretation is possible of even short sentences. I've learned that from years of arguing the inerrancy of the Bible and the Koran with fundamentalists for decades. The takeaway for me is that you admit that they've carefully worded their claims so as to not give the overt impression that they provide tools for clinical medical diagnoses. All the claims you quoted are well within the realm of possibility based upon the tagging of genetic markers. For comparison, I'm an EMS provider. We are taught all through school that we don't diagnose Yeah, but that's actually not because you couldn't be of a huge help with early diagnoses. It's because you have strict liability concerns thanks to a tort system that consistently reinforces suboptimal emergency medical outcomes in the name of risk reduction. I hardly think that your industry's lowest-common-denominator liability concerns are a good basis for how we treat cutting edge genetic tagging and correlation services. At the end of the day, I didn't pay 23andMe to become a member so that I could learn of the handful of markers and correlations that could pass muster with bureaucrats at the FDA. And if I weren't willing to pay for that handful of markers for $99, I certainly wouldn't want to pay a lot more for a service that couldn't achieve economies of scale at $99 because they had to CYA to such a high degree. I'm an adult who consents to 23andMe to have my saliva, pull out markers and do their best to show me correlations that might interest me. Why is the desire to have that liberty so difficult to understand?