4 ms·
>>Capitalism == free markets == non-coersion Wrong. Capitalism is synonymous with free enterprise, not free markets. And free enterprise simply means that ente
by enraged_camel 13y ago
>>Capitalism == free markets == non-coersion
Wrong. Capitalism is synonymous with free enterprise, not free markets. And free enterprise simply means that enterprises (rather than states) own the means of production.
- tokenizer 13y agoAgreed. We can definitly have unrestricted free markets with community owned syndicates and still be able to create tailored products and respond to demans. IMO, we need to start talking about workplace democracy if we're going to continue to entertain the idea of corporate controlled society, so that the common person can at least get their vote back (indirectly, by choosing who leads the company which bribes officials...).
- javert 13y agoIMO, we need to stop having people control one another. There is no self-interested reason to do it, from anyone's point of view.
- tokenizer 13y agoI definitely agree with you. I subscribe to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarian_socialism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarian_socialism. That said, many, many, people believe that most people are not competent, and need to be taken care of/controlled/limited. Arguments I usually have to fight against are: What to do about crime. What to do about "evil" people. What to do about property rights. What to do about control in decisions.
- javert 13y agoI think "libertarian socialism" is a worse than worthless contradiction. There is a simple solution to all the problems you mention, which is to have a government that uses retaliatory force, but not initiatory force. America had one for about a century, and now there is the intellectual machinery needed to go back to that system and to define and defend it much more vigorously. Unfortunately, a majority of "advocates for freedom" are mucking around with things like "libertarian socialism" and "anarcho-capitalism" which are contradictions in terms and won't work.
- tokenizer 13y ago> I think "libertarian socialism" is a worse than worthless contradiction. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWdd6_ZxX8c http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWdd6_ZxX8c
- javert 13y agoWell, most libertarians are subjectivists. There is no possibility of objective knowledge of reality. You're showing your true colors. Unfortunately for you (until or unless you stop fighting the truth), objective knowledge is possible.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- javert 13y agoNope. Your definitions are contradictory. There is no such thing as a "free enterprise" without a "free market", and vice versa. To the degree you do not have a "free market," you have government regulation. To the degree you have government regulation, successful enterprises are organs of the state. Free markets == free enterprise == capitalism. Why? Because they all just fall out of "the government only uses force to stop other people from initiating force and retaliating against them when they do," which is a proper government. And, as a sidenote, this is what the US Founding Fathers set up, to the closest extent they could.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>There is no such thing as a "free enterprise" without a "free market", and vice versa. Your understanding of what is meant by "free enterprise" is false. Source: I have a degree in Economics and wrote my senior's thesis on this subject. "Free enterprise" in this context means the enterprise has internal freedom - i.e. it is owned and controlled by non-state actors, as in people like you and me. These non-state actors can do whatever they want. Yes, there are still rules and regulations they operate under, but this does not mean that they are not free. The language "free enterprise" is specifically used to distinguish capitalism from communism, where the state controls the means of production, i.e. the enterprises (e.g. factories) are owned by the government, which typically exerts authoritarian control over them and determines what should be produced and how. The enterprises in communism have no internal freedom: they follow the government's orders. If the government says the factory should produce computers, that's what the factory produces. If the governments says it should produce tanks, that's what it produces. Whereas in capitalism, enterprises can produce whatever they want as long as they do it legally. They are still free.
- javert 13y ago> Yes, there are still rules and regulations they operate under, but this does not mean that they are not free. Under rules and regulations, an enterprise is not free to allocate its capital at it desires, produce the products it desires, market them in the way it desires, and sell them to who it desires. The degree to which that is true depends on the scope of the rules and regulations. If the only one is that there is a 5% income tax, the enterprise loses 5% of its freedom to allocate its capital. In reality, in our mixed economy, companies operate under many, many restrictions. In areas like finance and telecom, we have full-on regulatory monopolies: an enterprise has no freedom without permission, and new permissions are not being granted. I am fully aware that academic economists consistently define things according to non-essentials, and the only thing I can do is reject that. A "free enterprise" must mean what the words "free" and "enterprise" mean in the English language. Anything else is a barrier to rational thinking. If economists want a word for an enterprise that can "do whatever it wants, but still operates under rules and regulations," they (properly) have to make a new word for it, not re-use existing words that mean something different. Actually, though, there already is a word for that: a "contradiction." An enterprise cannot be free and not-free. Unfortunately, many academic economists want to "earn" their bread and butter by peddling contradictions to students and the public, and they deserve the very highest moral condemnation for it. Why? Because that kind of behavior leads to recessions (such as the perma-recession we are currently in), depressions, and the rise of authoritarianism (fascism being one example from recent history). It leads to suffering and mass-killing. Source: Reality. To the degree that you are a victim of this, you should rethink your views. To the degree that you are a perpetrator (if at all), you should be ashamed of yourself.