4 ms·
> Not mentioned in the article is that the "immersion heater" required power The tech data page specifies 200kW input power
by zokier 13y ago
> Not mentioned in the article is that the "immersion heater" required power
The tech data page specifies 200kW input power
- lutusp 13y ago> > Not mentioned in the article is that the "immersion heater" required power > The tech data page specifies 200kW input power Yes, but you see, that is a marketing claim, not a physical one. If it were true, Rossi would be sequestered with a team of crack lawyers attempting to secure patent protection for his breakthrough, rather than trying to sign people up to buy his unprotected, yet-to-be-built device. Also, why doesn't Rossi use 200 KW of the claimed 1 MW output power to sustain the reaction, thus removing the input power requirement? This "fact sheet" reads very differently to someone who actually understands physics.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Yes, but you see, that is a marketing claim, not a physical one. If it were true, Rossi would be sequestered with a team of crack lawyers attempting to secure patent protection for his breakthrough As for patents on perpetual motion devices, the Patent Office is geared to reject claimed cold fusion patents that don't include a demonstration of a working device (of course, the reason for this is such claims have proven irreproducible, which impinges on the utility test for patentability.)
- BerislavLopac 13y agoShouldn't this be a requirement for all patents?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Shouldn't this be a requirement for all patents? It has to demonstrate utility for all patents; but utility doesn't generally require a working device (even for patents of a "device" type). Whether it should is an interesting question, but if its clear from the information in the patent and the information generally available outside of it that a practitioner in the field could derive real utility from the described mechanism, I think there's at least a clear argument that actually having a demonstrated device is unnecessary, while with ones whose claims appear to violate physical laws or be of a class where claims have shown to be impossible to reproduce by other practitioners, the demonstration of a working device to demonstrate utility is important.
- pavlov 13y agoThe first shipping generators will have an unfortunate bug that caps the output at approximately one-fifth of maximum capacity. The company will promise that, as soon as the bug is fixed and some new parts are installed, the machines will deliver the promised 1 MW.
- VonGuard 13y agoThink this is what happened with the ECAT the DoD bought?
- lutusp 13y agoThe DoD did not buy one of these with my tax dollars -- tell me it isn't so. Because if they did, by now they would have exposed this scammer to justify the expenditure of public funds. It's a hoax -- the "fact sheet" has more holes than a Swiss cheese.
- stox 13y agoIf it needs a heater, wouldn't it be warm fusion then?
- astrodust 13y agoConsidering fusion in the sun happens at 15 million degrees K, then anything in the hundreds of degrees is considered "cold".
- Yetanfou 13y agoIf this thing produces 1 MW in heat output for a 200 KW power input, it is no more efficient than a good heat pump (with a COP of 5, not unusual in large-size installations)...
- lafar6502 13y agoMy quick calculation below shows that the device is not capable of 1MW power output with declared parameters (amount of heated water produced). It's calculated maximum power output would be like 160-180kW, which strangely is quite similar to declared input power. So it's not a heat pump, it's an ordinary (but expensive) electric boiler ;) I only wonder what it does with all that nickel and hydrogen...