4 ms·
"We've heard a good bit in this courtroom about public key encryption," said Albright. "Are you familiar with that?" "Yes, I am," said Diffie, in what
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
"We've heard a good bit in this courtroom about public
key encryption," said Albright. "Are you familiar with
that?"
"Yes, I am," said Diffie, in what surely qualified as the
biggest understatement of the trial.
"And how is it that you're familiar with public key
encryption?"
"I invented it."
I think I see the trailer for the TV Mini series right there :-)
- hobs 13y agoAnd they still lost... what? Every time I read about our patent system the blood drains from my face, how do we fix such a broken system?
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoIts worth thinking what do we want? - That we have good and effective Intellectual Property laws. It seems one of the big lessons of the Industrial revolution was the right property laws. The principles behind patents and copyright law make sense in this regard. Its the specifics that have problems. - The analogy to physical property is worth following more deeply - countries such as in S America, ie Chilie, are trying to undergo property law revolutions, and often local knowledge is clear - everyone "knows" that Juan lives in that building and has done since he was born, and maintains it for his family. Therefore it is "his" house. Our IP laws generally need to come to some agreement on a similar situation - where there is clear contentious dispute, local (ie expert) knowledge is needed. - This is more or less what is happening here - someone is claiming Juan's house was actually their house. A jury was asked to decide with clear expert local knowledge. So the process is what we want. Its just in this example we choose a bunch of idiots for the jury. - Software should be copyright. This will cause difficulties in "porting" software, and in doing the same algorithm in php and then perl. summary: IP rights is more likely to be a good thing than a bad thing, just like property rights. However bad implementations of property law have seemingly held back countries like Brazil / Chile, and we do not really know what IP law should look like to be most suited. I prefer allowing local knowledge to be primary in cases of dispute. (http://www.ted.com/talks/niall_ferguson_the_6_killer_apps_of_prosperity.html http://www.ted.com/talks/niall_ferguson_the_6_killer_apps_of...)
- zanny 13y ago> The principles behind patents and copyright law make sense in this regard. I personally disagree strongly with IP in the first place. Of course, this leads to a divisive opposition against the current regime between those who still want IP and those who don't, but it is something I feel strongly enough about I am not willing to concede on. Things are awful right now, and having "better" IP would reduce the likelihood of an open information society because people would be even more complicit if the laws weren't so laughably bad right now.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoIt is anecdotal but I think of the invention of forceps - incredibly useful for midwifery but kept secret for fear of losing money. I think that Diffie et al did actually invent something in mathematics. They were able to publish in an environment where their claim to invention would be respected and they could reasonably expect to profit from it (in career terms). This is the nice, fluffy level where everyone publishes for the common good. I am all for that. I just don't think that works for a world where the majority of value is exepcted to arise from not physical labour but the application of intelligence (to physical labour) As a simple example - I build a concrete "squirting" robot that like a dot matrix puts dabs of concrete down on the ground, and with some darn clever software it can build a house or a office block. I think I should have to choice whether to release that code as free, or if I make all building companies pay me royalties. How we enforce that I do not know, but I do know that I would rather live in a world that has the problem of working out how to share out the value created by robots that build everything, than potentially strangle it in its crib.
- dreamdu5t 13y agoI'd rather live in a world where you didn't invent your robot then one where you have sole discretion over who gets to build anything in its likeness. IP isn't about whether you own the robot you built, it's about whether you own similar robots other people built.
- 13y ago
- bborud 13y agoIt is unfixable because people think that fixing it is a solution. It isn't. Patents need to be abolished completely. The world for which they were designed does not exist anymore.
- tbrownaw 13y agoIt never did exist; new inventions tend to (1) come from people who invent them for the purpose of using them themselves, and (2) be invented by several people at around the same time. OTOH, the existence of patents gives people a reason to keep their ongoing research secret, and so maybe moves us closer to the world they were designed for. Patents exist for the purpose of alleviating problems which mostly only exist in a world that has patents.