5 ms·
"How can that be? College degrees bring higher income, but at today's cost they can't make up the savings they consume and the debt they add early in the life o
by tokenadult 17y ago
"How can that be? College degrees bring higher income, but at today's cost they can't make up the savings they consume and the debt they add early in the life of a typical student."
That's a very interesting analysis. I've read for a while now that for many young people who pursue college degrees, the economic return of the investment to gain the degree is actually negative. There are some broader societal implications here too, as much of funding for college study is third-party payment funded by taxes on people who never attend college at all. Some economists of education, notably Mark Blaug, point out that public subsidies for college study are massive wealth transfers from the poor to the rich.
- Alex3917 17y agoAll investment in formal education is a net negative, from pre-k onward. Right now my town spends about 11k per student per year, not including extraordinary expenses. Multiply this by 13 years, and it comes out to 143k. Let's say that instead of investing 11k in each student every year, my town just put 143k in an account for me on the day I was born. From the town's perspective this is feasible given the current tax structure, since we are doing this for each student instead of spending that money on schools. Furthermore, let's say that my parents had invested the money they spent on pre-k in that account on the day they would have otherwise paid tuition. This means that we are adding, say, 8k per year at age 3 and 4. Furthermore, let's say that we add 20k to the account for each of the four years between ages 18 and 22. Then we invest the whole thing in smallcap stocks. Assuming we can get a 10% return per year, then by my chubby-fingered iPhone math this looks like I'd have had ~1.2m in the bank by age 22.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- scott_s 17y agoAnd after no education, what is your 22-year-old self qualified to do?
- Alex3917 17y agoWho said anything about no education? Also, I'd have started working at age 16, and I didn't even add any of that income into the mix. Even assuming I was making minimum wage for the first five years I'd easily have enough money to retire by age thirty.
- scott_s 17y agoHow would you gain that education? Keep in mind that without public money, most of our educational infrastructure wouldn't exist - including universities.
- randallsquared 17y agoAh, just as grocery stores didn't exist before the taxes that support them. Hm. Wait.
- jibiki 17y agoBut grocery stores cost money! I don't think Alex can simultaneously claim: 1. A million-odd dollars in savings by the age of 22 by forgoing public education 2. An education by the age of 22 At very least, it requires some justification.
- Alex3917 17y agoHomeschooling, competitive athletics, community engagement, apprenticeships, mentors, freelancing, boostrapping, public libraries. And maybe a Ph.D. someday just for fun.
- scott_s 17y agoHomeschooling isn't free. Your suggestion is basically school-vouchers with no strings attached. For the kids whose parents want them to get an education, they would use that 11k a year to help pay for it - either private schools, tutors, educational materials and food. (If you, like me, went to a public school, then about a third of your food on the weekdays was heavily subsidized by the school system. Normal lunch at my high school cost $1.55 ten years ago - the food I ate cost more than that.)
- aswanson 17y agoWhat small cap index over 22 years returned 10 percent annually?
- Alex3917 17y agoI was being conservative, historically it's been 12%.
- aswanson 17y agoOver what time frame? Morningstar seems to paint a different picture, at least over the last decade: http://corporate.morningstar.com/US/asp/popup.aspx?xmlfile=2649.xml&filter=$MSCP.xml&page=SECTOR http://corporate.morningstar.com/US/asp/popup.aspx?xmlfile=2...