3 ms·
The original Anglo-Saxon juries were chosen from among local people because they knew the witnesses who would be testifying. The idea was that they could judge
by bradleyjg 13y ago
The original Anglo-Saxon juries were chosen from among local people because they knew the witnesses who would be testifying. The idea was that they could judge the credibility of the witnesses based on their direct experience with them.
Then later on after the idea of an unbiased jury took hold, there arose a justifying theory that the jury could tell by careful observation whether or not a witness was telling the truth. This theory is dubious enough when applied to simple questions of outright lying. When it comes to judging expert witnesses testimony, it is totally bogus.
If they don't want to create a patent office court to adjudicate these cases, at the very least Congress should authorize the appointment of special masters to do fact finding in patent cases.
- rdtsc 13y agoMoreover, there is a cottage industry of being an "expert" to testify for some of these technical issues. They are often experts in as much as they have been called before as "experts", even thought the industry they are supposedly explaining might consider them charlatans -- people who just know how to dress well and talk bullshit, but in a very convincing tone.
- codeka 13y agoThat's basically how I saw them trying to paint Diffie in this trial: by pointing out that he hadn't graduated from university, that he wasn't a professor, that he didn't even invent PKC! It seems they managed to convince the jury at least.
- danielweber 13y agoIf he claimed to invent PKC and the other side points out he hadn't, his credibility goes down the toilet. I saw lots of love for Diffie's "I invented it" line. But if he overplayed his hand, he ended up hurting his side more than he helped it.
- gknoy 13y agoWhen there are museums that consider you to have invented it, and you DID invent it (just perhaps were not the first, though that was not known at the time), it seems fair to say that you did. After all, we consider that both Newton and Leibnitz invented calculus.
- danielweber 13y agoThen he should have said that. "I am often called the inventor of public key cryptography.[1]" But it would not have been as cool to quote on web forums. [1] I don't know if that's heresy or whatever; Egghead's legal team, however, would know and could coach him appropriately.
- phaus 13y ago>If they don't want to create a patent office court to adjudicate these cases, at the very least Congress should authorize the appointment of special masters to do fact finding in patent cases. I'm not sure if special appointments of patent office courts would help. Look at the people congress places on technology commissions. Some of them wear their badges of technological ignorance as if its something to be proud of.