3 ms·
I don't understand how GoldieBlox are positioned as the victims here when they were the ones to initiate a lawsuit and accuse the rightsholders of being bad act
by kevingadd 13y ago
I don't understand how GoldieBlox are positioned as the victims here when they were the ones to initiate a lawsuit and accuse the rightsholders of being bad actors. Getting a letter from a rightsholder when you use their work without permission for PROFIT is not exactly an unexpected turn of events.
If this were just some sort of educational or satirical video then I'd be more willing to be on their side about this, but it's obvious they're looking to sell product. If they're going to use someone else's work without permission to make money, they should be willing to face the consequences (or at least pay the normal royalties you pay when covering a song).
- ganeumann 13y agoIf you send a letter to someone threatening them with legal action, they will often initiate legal action to have the court decide if your legal action would succeed. I don't know what the Beastie Boys said to GoldieBlox, but the EFF article mentions that GoldieBlox was worried that the Beastie Boys would initiate litigation right at the holiday season, leaving them without a commercial. GoldieBlox decided to ask a court to decide earlier. There's nothing wrong with this. It does point out an interesting lesson, though: never explicitly threaten someone with legal action, they might very well take the opportunity to pre-emptively sue, and if you were just posturing you'll now be spending a lot of money on lawyers. (This is why letters that are pretty much threatening to sue will instead say something like "We trust you will stop injuring us. If you do not, we reserve all rights.")
- fatman 13y agoThis tactic is even more common in Patent law. If you get the jump on the would-be plantiff you get to pick the venue, and hopefully stay out of the Patent-holder rubber stamp that is the Eastern District of Texas.