5 ms·
Give me a break. Do you think that racism is justified just because you let black people ride in the back of the buss? Arguments that the back of the buss is eq
by belorn 13y ago
Give me a break. Do you think that racism is justified just because you let black people ride in the back of the buss? Arguments that the back of the buss is equally good as the front of the buss is not good enough. If you think that putting in nicer seats will be a useful observation of the effects of racism, think again.
Instead of using those fixed up back seats as a bad argument in favor of racism, be honest with yourself. You simply want to continue a society that separate one part of society (black, poor, kids), from you (white, rich, old enough to be working with a high paid job).
Btw, I do produce content for free. My tax money however goes to support the restriction of 12 years old who want to learn physics. I think that is not the compromise that copyright is intended to be, or should exist in a moral society.
- lelandbatey 13y agoI think you've wandered a bit far from the original point with this talk of racism. More back to the first, I think it's an unavoidable fact that if you create something you are allowed to dictate the terms of using, consuming, or experiencing that thing. That means I can make something, and then I can require people to pay to use it/see it/experience it. And I don't think we can get away from that. I also don't think we have can say that violating that right is an act of integrity.
- belorn 13y agoIf you create something, you are perfectly fine in dictating the terms of it. I just don't agree that you should require society to punish children who want to learn. Your dictating ends at that point, since its not a good compromise for society to make. If you still want to continue dictate the terms of using, consuming, or experiencing the thing you made, you got to do it without the help from the government. You want to get paid, and you want the governments help to do so. Fine. Make a compromise that benefit both side and do no harm to groups we don't expect to be working at any rate. It should not be such a hard thing.
- Amadou 13y agoI think it's an unavoidable fact that if you create something you are allowed to dictate the terms of using, consuming, or experiencing that thing. I have to disagree 100%. Once you publish something you lose all effective control over it. It is only this legal fiction we call copyright that gives copyright owners any sort of control. But even maximalist copyright regimes are full of more holes than swiss cheese - if anything, the more they ratchet up the controls the more people seek out the holes. It is human nature to share knowledge, modern copyright is about fighting human nature and that never works out (c.f. the war on drugs).
- tedunangst 13y agoOnce you publish something you lose all effective control over it. If I'm trying to decide whether to publish something or not, this is not the argument that's going to make me give the green light.
- Amadou 13y agoIt is not an argument, it is a statement of fact, like saying water is wet. There is an implicit assumption in your position that copyright based compensation is the only method of compensation. It isn't. It wasn't even the dominant method until the last couple of centuries when technology made it feasible. Now that technology has moved on, our economic systems need to keep up.
- criley2 13y ago"It is not an argument, it is a statement of fact, like saying water is wet." Oh nonsense. You're ignoring the legal system, which is hilarious, because you're talking about a LEGAL construct. So yes in your little hypothetical world where copyright exists AND there is no legal system, sure, copyright has no effect and you have no control. But otherwise, saying "if you publish you lose all control" it's like saying "if you go out in public you lose all control over what happens to you. Mugging... rape... murder... you have zero control". It ignores the legal system, and your ability to seek punishment or compensation for being wronged under the law. I don't understand the value of such an asinine hypothetical. In the real world: you do retain control of what you publish after you publish it. If you think otherwise: Mickey Mouse would like to have a word with you.