7 ms·
Those very morally justification that demands 12 year olds to work and earn a pay if they want to learn physics, rather than just letting them learn. Or that m
by belorn 13y ago
Those very morally justification that demands 12 year olds to work and earn a pay if they want to learn physics, rather than just letting them learn.
Or that morally justification that only allows a rich 12 year old child to listen to music from all around the world, and learn to be a great musician.
Or that morally justification that only allows a rich 12 year old child to watch movies and become a move creator of culture and thus learn from the past.
Or that morally justification that only allows a rich 12 year old child to experience a wide range of video games, so he later get inspired to make new fantastic and wonderful games.
Or that morally justification that only allows a rich 12 year old to use images programs to create images of art, or advanced physic emulators to become the next Einstien.
After all, the creator of copyrighted works need to get paid, and restricting 12 years old in learning is the only moral superior way to force such payments.
- tptacek 13y agoThis is an analysis that comes from simultaneously valorizing popular culture consumer products while denying the producers of those products a livelihood. It makes absolutely no sense in any case; where does the analysis end? Does freedom from copyright end at age 12, or should huge companies be allowed to ignore the GPL?
- belorn 13y agoIt doesn't make much sense in restricting a 12 year old from learning physics. Just because one do not like the alternative, it doesn't make it any nicer, moral, or right. If one can not accept that a business model based on restricting 12 year old from learning is wrong, can copyright ever become the compromise between society and the promotion of the Progress of Science and useful Arts that was once promised?
- bediger4000 13y agoShould we give producers of those products a livelihood at the expense of warping the rest of society? Because enforcing something like "intellectual property" is going to change society a whole lot. The enforcement is going to start with very invasive snooping, and end with stifling most inventions and innovations. I personally am not willing to go that far. It's pretty clear that right now, "intellectual property" is mainly an instrument of control, to keep incumbent companies in power. Personally, I don't get a lot out of popular (or really, any other) music. It's fine with me to let the market decide on prices without state enforced monopolies, temporary or otherwise. I believe that there's a whole lot of people who can and will make music and other art even if the state doesn't enforce monopolies for them. Indeed, society might get a lot more music: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1336802 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1336802
- tptacek 13y agoOnly on a message board does charging money for a Miley Cyrus track count as "warping society". Frankly, I think society is warped by us not charging enough to deter listeners.
- sounds 13y agotptacek, you and I have exchanged comments before when it comes to copyright. What's the real issue here? Previously you've argued that the copyright industry actually has the stronger set of morals, and those violating copyright are somehow the "bad guys" in this debate. Now you're arguing that society is warped and all content is trash ("a Miley Cyrus"). I may be trying to accomplish the impossible by being rational here, but level with me. Why the love for copyright? I admit that copyright may have a useful purpose. I feel like the usefulness expires about 10 years after the work has been created. I feel strongly that the current laws and the corporations who largely depend on those laws to make a profit represent a parasite that exploits 12 year olds and other underprivileged people. You do wonderful analysis of cryptosystems. This isn't much different, right? It can be deconstructed analytically, the problem identified, and at least on a message board the propaganda can be debunked. ("You wouldn't steal a car. Stealing is wrong." Copyright violation IS NOT stealing.)
- yareally 13y ago> tptacek, you and I have exchanged comments before when it comes to copyright. What's the real issue here? From reading many of tptacek's comments over the years on HN, I think he sometimes plays devil's advocate to encourage discussion.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, like (I think) most people who don't spend a lot of time on nerd message boards, I think pirating content (of all stripes) is deeply unethical and harmful.
- 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- criley2 13y agoThink of the children! Give me a break with the theatrics. You're basically saying "doesn't my extraordinary case justify copyright infringement / theft?" No, it doesn't. It justifies you getting off your rear and making resources for 12 year old kids to learn and play and experience FOR FREE. The existence of commercial products doesn't negate free stuff. So why not let the 12 year olds use any of the free and open source and widely available stuff? If you think that the stuff produced for free isn't as good as the copyrighted stuff, isn't that itself a useful observation of the effects of copyright? Instead of using those 12 year olds as a prop piece for a bad argument, put your money where your mouth is and go out there and produce content for them that will inspire them, without forcing them to break copyright to be inspired.
- belorn 13y agoGive me a break. Do you think that racism is justified just because you let black people ride in the back of the buss? Arguments that the back of the buss is equally good as the front of the buss is not good enough. If you think that putting in nicer seats will be a useful observation of the effects of racism, think again. Instead of using those fixed up back seats as a bad argument in favor of racism, be honest with yourself. You simply want to continue a society that separate one part of society (black, poor, kids), from you (white, rich, old enough to be working with a high paid job). Btw, I do produce content for free. My tax money however goes to support the restriction of 12 years old who want to learn physics. I think that is not the compromise that copyright is intended to be, or should exist in a moral society.
- lelandbatey 13y agoI think you've wandered a bit far from the original point with this talk of racism. More back to the first, I think it's an unavoidable fact that if you create something you are allowed to dictate the terms of using, consuming, or experiencing that thing. That means I can make something, and then I can require people to pay to use it/see it/experience it. And I don't think we can get away from that. I also don't think we have can say that violating that right is an act of integrity.
- throwawaykf 13y agoIf you think any non-negligible fraction of people infringing copyright are looking for education or inspiration, I have a bridge to sell you.
- Intermernet 13y agoI know you're probably getting at the point that people infringe copyright mainly for the purposes of "entertainment", but entertainment, education and inspiration aren't mutually exclusive. Most scientists and artists have probably been inspired and educated by something that also entertained them.