4 ms·
Note: I am firm believer is[sic] Eugenics, so I might be a bit biased. You might want to explain that a bit further, before you get associated with the tragic
by nitrogen 13y ago
Note: I am firm believer is[sic] Eugenics, so I might be a bit biased.
You might want to explain that a bit further, before you get associated with the tragic events of the early 20th century and downvoted into oblivion.
- cema 13y agoI believe there is no such thing as "downvoted into oblivion" any longer. Still, the point about Eugenics is valid: even without the unfortunate associations with the events of the previous century, the term is rather vague.
- derefr 13y agoThe GP could mean any of several things, none of which have to do with those events (EDIT: he means 1 and the converse-corollary of 3): 1. Auto-eugenics: the ethical obligation one feels, when one knows they have horrible DNA, to adopt instead of breed. 2. Eugenic engineering: currently, this means "do IVF, look at the zygotes, and pick the healthiest ones to try to implant." In the future, this could involve genetic patches from healthy donors ("gene cleaning") or just plain hacked-in transhuman bonus features. 3. Eugenics, under the original botanical definition of the term: pairing people with really great DNA, and encouraging them to breed as much as possible, and repeating this process over several generations. We already vaguely do this naturally by interpreting health-signals like height or breast size as indicative of mating potential, and we're doing it more explicitly when we select good sperm/eggs from a donor clinic to pair to our own. (The final sci-fi-ish step in this one would be for women to volunteer to/get paid to/pay to (depending on supply vs, demand) "adopt at conception" genetically-"optimized" children matched by the clinics themselves. This would probably be in addition to the gene-cleaning techniques from 2.) Oh, and I guess I should mention this last one, which is closest to the "problematic" version but which, surprisingly, has been attempted to success (i.e. Nobody being unhappy with the arrangement): 4. Libertarian eugenics: Pay people you'd be afraid of reproducing, to not have kids any more. This could be a state rent-transfer, but it's also possible to make it an entirely bottom-up process: any individual activist with some money to give can do their own "vigilante eugenics," finding, say, crack-addicted mothers and offering a lump-sum to get their tubes tied[1]. And this has happened: http://www.radiolab.org/story/251887-what-if-no-destiny/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/251887-what-if-no-destiny/ Really, "the bad eugenics" is a ghost from the past, more an artefact of Nazi beliefs about racial purity than any productive approach to solving the problem. --- [1] Okay, this is less "eugenics" and more "euteratogenics" plus a little "euepigenics." But we're making people here, not show-grade Dalmatians; we care about more than their potential as good breeding stock.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoOr a simple and "ethical" explanation - make sure partner you are getting offspring with has DNA that minimizes chance of inheritable diseases. If everyone follows same logic in a few generations inheritable diseases would be less dominant. In particular let's look at OP's example - he has mutations in different genes, so he is not is risk group for the disease that 23andme mistakenly reported him for. However if he would have an an offspring with someone who has complementary mutation in same genes, the offspring would stand much higher chance of inheriting that disease.
- figglesonrails 13y agoI don't know about you, but it's rather hard to ensure that your partner has the "right mix". It's hard enough to secure a mate as is! :) Instead, I suppose the suggestion would, "Well, go adopt!", which is a less than satisfactory answer for probably like 99.9% of all of the public, seeing as how nobody bothers to get a "genetic checkup" before they reproduce, and we're pretty much wired to prefer our own offspring to others when it comes to parental investment. All in all, the only context I've ever really heard these sorts of conversations in seem to be surrounding people who have terrible conditions that they are afraid of passing on, not two otherwise healthy individuals who have no idea whether or not their offspring could inherit some kind of genetic disorder that it latent in them. Yes, that is the problem isn't it? Also, given the amount [read:lack] of effort in "planning" that some people seem to put into reproduction, I wouldn't be surprised if this remains the problem...forever.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoIs it? Fundamentally this is just a search problem. Pair up 23andme with a dating site and match only people with below certain threshold of possibility* of an offspring having genetically inherited diseases. * Let's say on average you have 10% chance of having your child inherit something bad. If you show only partners that have this value halved over time you will see a positive trend.
- aaronem 13y ago
- hedgie13 13y agoI wonder were on the spectrum of eugenics this foundation belongs: http://www.jewishgeneticdiseases.org/ http://www.jewishgeneticdiseases.org/